3 ms·
If you combine DC and Maryland, it makes Maryland go from the 19th largest state to the 10th. DC is bigger than 19 states, why not let it have its own represen
by jedberg 6y ago
If you combine DC and Maryland, it makes Maryland go from the 19th largest state to the 10th. DC is bigger than 19 states, why not let it have its own representation?
Edit: I mixed up DC and Puerto Rico. Forget what I said.
- Simulacra 6y agoI think you don’t understand how large the district of Columbia is. You can drive across it in about 15 minutes. The district of Columbia is tiny, there are not 19 states that are smaller, and I challenge you to list them
- greenburger 6y agoYou’re mixing up Puerto Rico and DC. DC population is only larger than Vermont and Wyoming.
- SllX 6y agoNo worries about the mixup, but I’ll at least answer the core of your question anyway: DC is bigger than a handful of States by population, but it is still just a carve out from Maryland. You could make a case for any of the top 20 cities by population to be their own State, but you need a limiting principle. DC does not have proper representation in Congress, and I think that’s a shame and worth addressing, but there is also a case to be made for Congress having some territory that it directly governs. Only problem is DC became cool and a place where a lot of people live. My compromise is to leave the city itself to be administered by Congress and the government it setup there, but to have Maryland administer elections and put DC back under Maryland law for civil, criminal and tax purposes.