4 ms·
> Or adopt D.C. statehood That would only add two, unless you also had a reapportionment act. Same with adding Puerto Rico as a state. Edit: As pointed out b
by jedberg 6y ago
> Or adopt D.C. statehood
That would only add two, unless you also had a reapportionment act. Same with adding Puerto Rico as a state.
Edit: As pointed out below, this is wrong. Since DC already has 3, it would actually lower the number by one, so this would in fact give an odd number.
> The House can and does have ties, even with an odd number of members; members abstaining or missing votes in the House are more common in the House than the EC.
Yeah, but when that happens, they just vote again. The are never deadlocked from a tie.
> You could extend the same EC voting arrangement to, say, (to pick an odd number of territories) Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Northern Mariana Islands as D.C. has now.
It would make sense to do this for Puerto Rico, whose population is greater than 20 states. But all the other territories are smaller than the smallest state, and that would give them outsize power.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> > Or adopt D.C. statehood > That would only add two, unless you also had a reapportionment act. Absent a change to the fixed number of seats of full House members, it would subtract one; D.C. currently has zero Senators out of 100, zero members of the House included in the apportionment of the fixed 435 seats (it has a delegate, which is separate), and 3 electoral votes. Absent a change to the legislated size of the House, with D.C. statehood it would have 2 senators out of 102, 1 member of the House within the fixed 435 total seats, and 3 electoral votes. The total size of the EC would be reduced by one seat.
- jedberg 6y agoThis is an excellent point. It would in fact reduce it by one, making an odd number.