4 ms·
TLDR: There's no way to tldr this, it's a pretty awesome essay. It's possibly the most extensive and elaborate essay I've ever read on an actual web page inst
by SkyMarshal 16y ago
TLDR: There's no way to tldr this, it's a pretty awesome essay. It's possibly the most extensive and elaborate essay I've ever read on an actual web page instead of a PDF or journal. Basically the author says:
"This article provides a detailed factual explanation of why software is mathematics, complete with the references in mathematical and computer science literature. It also includes a detailed factual explanation of why mathematics is speech, complete once again with references."
The implication being that if software is mathematics (and/or speech), it can't be patented. IANAL but I've suspected that a clear and elaborate delineation of the equivalence of software and math/logic has been one big things missing in this debate, and its absence has allowed patent trolls to prosper much more than they would have otherwise.
Does anyone know of any other efforts like this to show software == math == logic?
- corin_ 16y agoYou began with "there's no way to tldr this" then moved on with "Basically the author says" and sumarised it?
- chc 16y agoThe obvious meaning to me is "Here's a summary. But no summary could really do justice to this article. You should read it."
- SkyMarshal 16y agoExactly.
- SkyMarshal 16y agoYeah, I was in a hurry as I was writing it and my brain got ahead of my typing and I completely forgot to add this line after my quotation of the author: > Then he goes on to do exactly that throughout the rest of the article. Yes it somewhat contradicts my assertion that there's no way to tldr it, but good tldr's usually condense not just the author's thesis but some of the most pertinent details as well. But in this case that is very difficult, at best.
- brlewis 16y agoAs I recall software == math == logic was one of the principles behind the Benson and Flook decisions of the U.S. Supreme Court. Then came Diehr, which didn't say anything had changed, but it was opportunistically read as if something had changed. Software is patentable today because our legal system is inconsistent. Law is not law.
- micks56 16y agoIn Benson and Flook, the claimed inventions were on algorithms and NOT tied to a machine. In Diehr, the inventor claimed "algorithm + machine" where machine was a computer. The Court looks at a computer as an infinitely configurable machine, with each new software algorithm creating a new invention. That is the distinction that the courts make between Benson/Flook and Diehr, which has allowed "software" patents to exist.
- brlewis 16y agoThat's grossly inaccurate. The rest of the Diehr patent included a combination of elements claimed to be novel, not a general-purpose computer.
- micks56 16y agoThe novelty was using a computer to do this, which no one had done before. Prior to this invention, curing rubber was done manually. Also, from my understanding an infinitely configurable computer and general-purpose computer aren't the same thing. Infinitely configurable means a new machine every time new software is installed, which would allow the invention to fall within the patent statutes. A general-purpose computer is not a new machine, has already been invented, and therefore trying to patent an "algorithm + GPC" would mean a patent on the algorithm, which is outside patent protection.
- brlewis 16y agoYour description of the claimed novelty differs wildly from the majority opinion in Diehr: http://brlewis.com/y/2004/diehr.htm http://brlewis.com/y/2004/diehr.htm According to the respondents, the continuous measuring of the temperature inside the mold cavity, the feeding of this information to a digital computer which constantly recalculates the cure time, and the signaling by the computer to open the press, are all new in the art.