3 ms·
> The best antidote for bad ideas and conspiracy theories is transparency and public debate. Have you actually tried that? I have. I spent quite a while when I
by tzs 6y ago
> The best antidote for bad ideas and conspiracy theories is transparency and public debate.
Have you actually tried that? I have. I spent quite a while when I was in law school on some Usenet groups where tax conspiracy theorists hung out, thoroughly refuting their arguments (it was a good way for me to practice legal research).
The problem was that the people who were coming up with the totally false but believable to people who only have a layman's understanding of law claims were easily able to do so faster than I and the other people also doing this could refute them.
- dhimes 6y agoYes, debate doesn't seem to work very well. The "persuaders" just pivot to another nonsense claim, and you waste a ton of time debunking it. It has to start with public culture. People should be a little embarrassed to be wrong; they should strive to be right. They should demand evidence. We're losing that. The rise of anti-intellectualism is allowing this fungus to grow and spread.
- 0xy 6y agoAre you proposing we censor and ban discussion of flat earth theories?
- dooglius 6y agoYou seem to be implying it didn't work, but how do you know? Sure, the other person didn't go "I admit defeat", but the ideas can sit and percolate. Also, your messages may have had an effect on lurkers.
- TigeriusKirk 6y agoGreat point. People saying "You know what, I was wrong" is incredibly rare in public internet forums. Nearly non-existent in a lot of places. But it doesn't mean that they didn't shift their beliefs. And if nothing else, they may not spread it again. You'll just likely never know.