12 ms·
On Our Abusive Relationship with Mozilla’s Firefox
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoHonestly, having Chrome purposefully cripple uBlock origin protections "for my safety", feels a lot more like gaslighting, than anything Mozilla is being accused of here.
- newscracker 6y ago> I implore everyone to think about this, and make a concious decision. Continue using Firefox if you want to, but don’t fool yourself that it means anything. Cool. Cool. Cool. Whatever floats your boat, right? I’ll continue using Firefox, thank you. I know about the issues and about Mozilla, but I’d feel really dirty, as if I’ve sold my soul, if I use Chrome or Chromium. There’s space for criticism, and there’s space for resignation. I’m not yet in the latter camp. Firefox, for all the issues over the past few years, is nowhere close to being dead or to be given up on, IMO.
- jlgaddis 6y agoExactly! I've been using Firefox for a looooong time -- since before it was "Firefox", actually! My name's in that full-page ad that was placed in the New York Times to commemorate the 1.0 release and, of course, I used Netscape before that. Over this time, Mozilla has certainly made some "goofs" (to put it nicely). They've done several things I wasn't real thrilled about -- especially in the last couple of years. The default settings should absolutely be tightened up. There are some valid criticisms in this article and I can't -- won't -- try to defend them. My own "preferences file" is several hundred lines long and gets installed on my machines before I launch Firefox for the first time because, yes, it makes an absurd number of outbound connections on startup. Firefox is the "mutt" of web browsers. They all suck, Firefox just sucks less. Even with all of the legitimate criticisms and screw-ups on Mozilla's part, Firefox is still a tremendous improvement over Google Chrome, which isn't allowed on my machines. The closest I come is having Chromium installed (from the Debian package repositories!) and that's reserved for the rare case when I need to use a different browser for a few minutes. Mozilla Firefox certainly isn't perfect, but it could be sooooo much worse!
- farias0 6y agoExactly. What's the point in giving up on Firefox? It's putting up a hell of a fight (except for some performance and a very occasional broken site I don't miss Chrome at all) and it's our only realistic hope. Why don't we try to fix Mozilla instead?
- xhkkffbf 6y ago$2mil? Really? That kind of puts a crack in the idea of it being a non-profit.
- dwighttk 6y agoHow?
- xhkkffbf 6y agoThe non-profits I know do things like raise money for the poor or indigent. The principals get paid a very basic rate. How many programmers could that $2m employ? How many folks could be hired to bridge the digital divide? I can think of many, many ways to spend that $2m besides making some exec richer. It seems like Mozilla is getting a huge check from Google, paying fancy salaries to some insiders, and then not paying taxes. In my mind, the word "non-profit" means an organization run with more than profit in mind. But maybe you just think it's a clever word for "lucky folks who don't pay taxes."
- dwighttk 6y agosalary and profit are different things
- xhkkffbf 6y agoOnly in name. To the exec bringing home $2m, it doesn't really matter whether it's called "salary" or "profit sharing." There might be a tax distinction, but the champagne will taste the same either way for the rich exec.
- dwighttk 6y agoExcept exec does pay taxes on salary ... You originally accused me of thinking “it's a clever word for "lucky folks who don't pay taxes."” I don’t understand either of your responses.
- 6y ago
- ouid 6y agoAs an end user of Firefox, I find it very frustrating that every update I allow to the browser wrests more control from me, and now I am being constantly annoyed to keep my browser up to date as well.
- acdha 6y ago> I am being constantly annoyed to keep my browser up to date as well. Imagine how annoyed you’d find it to have all of your accounts compromised and your personal data out in public or held for ransom. We know that most people don’t install updates in a timely manner because we have 3 decades of evidence from billions of devices.
- ouid 6y agoThe question is not when I will install my updates, but if. Generally the answer is that I won't apply any patches at all. If you refuse to acknowledge that updates a) also introduce bugs, and b) consistently have negative impacts on the software, then I don't see how we can possibly have an honest conversation about this. I certainly do not consider the security of my browsing experience to be such an important factor that I am willing to sacrifice all of my autonomy to obtain marginally more of it. This is the same argument that has been applied countless times to all sorts of monetization and surveillance disguised as security. I simply accept the risks.
- dralley 6y agoSwitch to the ESR build, then.
- acdha 6y agoThis is like trying to argue that cars shouldn't have safety equipment because you don't want to pay for something you don't [yet] agree you need. A web browser is extremely complex and usually the most security-sensitive software most people use. You don't have the resources to maintain a fork so if you really dislike the decisions made by the Mozilla developer team, switch to a different browser rather than making your browser experience worse and putting yourself at risk.
- probably_wrong 6y agoI feel it for the post's author - few things are as demoralizing as finding out that your heroes are flawed, which Mozilla definitely is. Having said that, the points he lists against Firefox are also perfectly valid criticisms of Chrome, so I fail to see how is switching to Chromium any better - if they got fed up with Firefox because they "shut down communication", just wait until they try to communicate with Google of all companies.
- prophesi 6y agoYeah, I didn't understand what the author was trying to get at. Every point made against Firefox, Chrome itself offends to an exponential degree. Their conclusion of using ungoogled-chromium makes no sense, as it still suffers from at least three of the five issues outlined. At least with Firefox, you have ESR to keep using the version you're accustomed to for a few years. Or you can jump over to TOR if you really distrust Mozilla that much with their opt-out user metrics. I agree that individual browser choices won't make any changes. But this is where we're at. At least there _is_ a choice. Legislation to break up the browser monopoly is likely our only hope.
- jx47 6y agoI think the difference between the criticism of Chrome and the criticism of Firefox lies in the marketing. Firefox is constantly telling me that they are the good guys. The last bastion of privacy and user-first on the web. But in reality they are doing a lot of questionable and shady stuff that that they need to be called out for.
- danShumway 6y agoWell sure, call them out on that stuff. But don't then finish that callout by saying that nothing matters and that trying to fight against browser monoculture is pointless. The "final thoughts" section of this article is depressing to read. There is absolutely still a difference between Mozilla and Google, and it is absolutely still worth fighting to avoid a browser monoculture, even if there's only a small chance of success. I definitely agree that Mozilla has problems, but that's not the thrust of this article. The thrust of the article is that Mozilla has problems, and therefore everyone's efforts to improve the web are meaningless.
- mistrial9 6y agopeople obsess about obsessions -- like Emotionally Abusive Relationships.. This post IMO is social anti-matter. proceed with caution... Personally I wish Firefox could stabilize and "keep on trucking", myself, warts and all. That means your f* crazy company too. Get Well Soon
- csmattryder 6y agoThe Megabar is such a surprisingly trivial hill for Mozilla to die on. I made a few posts on the subreddit about it, I saw numerous others with the same complaint - the motion is unnecessary and distracting. It's a common enough opinion that surely an about:config preference could warrant being tossed in. I ended up moving browsers, and as a consequence, all web projects I build will have first-class support for my browser of choice, with Firefox/Gecko testing later on when time allows. As a consequence of that, the web performs worse in Firefox. I'll be back, as soon as the next UI revolution happens, but until then competitors have free-reign to attempt to permanently win me over.
- pitaj 6y agoIt seems more like a weird hill for you to die on.
- pornel 6y agoIt's an amazing echo chamber. 7 pixels in the address bar were the end of Mozilla. In reality, most people who browse the Web barely know what address bar is, and couldn't care less how much padding it has. I use Nightly and haven't even noticed when it changed. I've only learned about the "controversy" after the fact. But then again, I must be a lunatic, because I think Pocket is useful.
- Ygg2 6y ago> I must be a lunatic, because I think Pocket is useful. There is another lunatic like me? Yeah, I like Pocket, it can't be trained like Google news. I wish I could use Pocket recommendations on desktop.
- dralley 6y ago>Yeah, I like Pocket, it can't be trained like Google news. I wish I could use Pocket recommendations on desktop. You... can? Unless I'm totally misunderstanding what you mean. Unless you're using a linux distro that compiles it out or something, it should be right there in as an option in about:preferences#home https://imgur.com/a/1Shcxoo https://imgur.com/a/1Shcxoo
- pornel 6y agoI hate that Firefox's privacy is held to a standard so high that's almost at a level of a conspiracy theory. As if Mozilla had some nefarious business in selling your captive portal DNS queries (so much private data in that IP address that isn't even yours!), but don't mind that trillion-dollar tracking-based ad network of the competitor. Mozilla is dragged for using Google Safe Browsing service and a limited version of Google Analytics, but the browser by maker of these services is the author's choice. When Firefox checks for updates that's Spyware Phoning Home, while the author of this complaint is probably logged in to Chrome with their real name and a verified phone number.
- gilrain 6y agoThe level is set by Firefox's own marketing. If they don't want to be held to their own claims, they should stop making them.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoI apologize for bringing up politics, but I truly believe it's a useful analogy: These takes remind me of the people who voted for Jill Stein in 2016. Like, cool, I can agree it would be great if there was a viable third option—but there's not, and there won't be until we change how we count votes, and your choice of protest is effectively taking what power you do have and throwing it away. If you want to call that an abusive relationship, I can understand where you're coming from—but it is the state of the world. You either work within the system you've been given, or you get crushed. There are more effective ways to advocate for change—you could focus on primary elections, or you could become more involved on Bugzilla. And just like in politics, I think if you actually do a tad of research into the web standards space, you'll see there are a ton of differences between what Mozilla and Google advocate for. I don't agree with all of Mozilla's positions, but I certainly agree with them more often than Google's. Edit: Yikes, I really didn't intend to completely derail the discussion! I'm sorry! :(
- dx87 6y agoI looked into third parties this year, and even if you know the party you voted for won't win, it isn't necessarily throwing your vote away. It turns out that if a party gets at least 5% of the popular vote, they are eligible to receive millions of dollars from the government to assist their campaign during the next election.
- Shared404 6y agoThat is actually some incredibly useful info. Thanks for pointing that out.
- vmception 6y agoYou consider that a good enough incentive? That's like a rationalization, a search for a silver lining because you made the wrong choice. Long term investments are short term investments gone wrong.
- bluejekyll 6y agoBecause most states (except Maine) use first-past-the post polling, this really only takes votes away from one of the major parties, and most likely from the more moderate one you might prefer. The GP is right, until RCV exists (or other plural voting option) it’s just throwing away your vote, or worse helping the more extreme candidate you don’t like. Edit: to be clear, first work inside your state to pass some form of plural voting, then support 3rd party candidates.
- LarvaFX 6y agoWhy can't we just pay 5 bucks per month everyone over patreon or something similar to them to keep doing servo and mdn?
- ffpip 6y agoSeems to be down https://web.archive.org/web/20201023091717/ruzkuku.com/txt/moz-rel.html https://web.archive.org/web/20201023091717/ruzkuku.com/txt/m...
- kmeisthax 6y ago>Patronizing, Dismissiveness and Shutting down communication This is why Free Software exists. If someone makes a software change you don't like, you (or someone else) are free to revert that change. Forking Firefox to remove the Megabar is certainly possible. Hell, there's forks of Firefox that revert process separation so that XUL Addons or NPAPI plugins still work! (Also, I never noticed this Megabar thing or understand why people would hate it.) >Threats and Using guilt Maybe, but the way this is described is wide enough to describe basically all political advocacy. Merely advocating for your cause by stating that the option of no action is worse is not in and of itself abusive. Did Mozilla act in such a way as to bring about the situation where Gecko is the only practical Blink alternative? >Digital spying and Denying something you know is true I'm not going to complain about people wanting to not have telemetry involved with their computing experience, but I am going to complain about the abuse of the word "spyware". No information is given as to what features of Firefox are being objected to in particular; just a link to another website with a "spyware removal guide" that, among other things, considers OCSP to be spyware. What brand of alternative facts are you high on to think that certificate revocation is an inherent privacy risk? >Financial control Oh hey, an actual problem with Mozilla as an organization! However, this does not directly affect people who just use Firefox. If you donate money to Mozilla, then this is a far more valid concern, but people who use Firefox need to be concerned with if their software is going to continue to be supported rather than if their money has been absconded with. >Unpredictability This is the first thing all over again. I'm starting to think the author of this post really just hates the Megabar and wrote the rest of the article around that.
- bantunes 6y ago> As already mentioned with the Megabar example, we can only guess what the Firefox developers will want to change in the next releases. Other examples might be FTP or RSS support. FTP predates the Web and is terrible. It should be dropped.
- timw4mail 6y agoOne of the things that really irritates me about Chrome (especially compared to Firefox) is how shady the tactics were to improve market share: * misleading webads * consistent performance "bugs" in other browsers * installation via other software as an opt-out download While I find some of the actions as Mozilla irritating, they just don't seem as evil.
- user764743 6y agoThis writer needs to learn the difference between it's and its, otherwise I agree completely.
- jlgaddis 6y agoThank you for your wonderful, enlightening contribution to the discussion.
- scoutt 6y ago> Digital spying and Denying something you know is true This is very interesting, and the linked page too[1]. As a long-time Firefox user I find this kind of shocking. I trusted no traffic (or no such traffic) was generated from Firefox. I need now to open a session with Wireshark and check it for myself. I wonder how the TOR browser handles all these requests. [1] https://spyware.neocities.org/guides/firefox.html https://spyware.neocities.org/guides/firefox.html
- jlgaddis 6y agoPrepare to be astonished, seriously! I'm a die-hard Firefox user (see my other comment here) but it's outrageous -- and (part of) the reason why my preferences file is so huge.
- rafram 6y agoThat “Firefox is Spyware” article which this one uses as evidence is total BS. Firefox is spyware because it makes a single GET request to an empty page on Mozilla’s site to detect public WiFi login portals? How else do they envision that working? Even if you’re technically adept, getting that login page to show up in the age of HTTPS is a hassle.
- austinl 6y agoI came to the comments specifically curious about this. I'm currently running Firefox with multi-container, and a couple of the about:config tweaks from https://www.privacytools.io/browsers/#about_config https://www.privacytools.io/browsers/#about_config Obviously it's all relative (e.g. compared to Tor), but is the general consensus that this is good enough?
- danShumway 6y ago"Good enough" depends entirely on your threat model and what you're trying to prevent. I don't know that anyone here can answer that question for you. That being said, the changes you made will make you more private than an unaltered Ungoogled Chromium build, and substantially more private than an unaltered Chrome install. I'm assuming you also have an adblocker installed (uBlock Origin recommended). If not, do that. Installing an adblocker is the easiest, most effective way to improve your privacy in terms of effort-to-payout, pretty much everyone everywhere even if they're non-technical should be running an adblocker; it should be the first step you take to improving your privacy. If you're comfortable with the annoyances that come from enabling more advanced Firefox features, I personally also use the uMatrix addon (discontinued, I'm still trying to figure out how to replace it) to disable Javascript by default. Depending on your privacy goals, that can be either a substantial gain in privacy, or a ton of overkill. And that conversation could go longer, we could talk about both the benefits and downsides of VPNs, canvas blocking, etc... again, I don't know what you mean by "good enough", privacy is a very wide spectrum. But if you're just looking to pick a browser, and you've followed the steps on that page to configure Firefox settings, I would say you've done pretty well for yourself compared to the average person browsing the web. Typically, if I'm setting up a computer for someone else, I'll just install Firefox, flip a few settings, and give them an adblocker. It's not unless I know someone's technical and they want stronger protections that I'll start talking about `resistFingerprinting` or disabling WebGL.
- dangus 6y agoReally weak criticisms here, if you ask me. - Mozilla moved my cheese one time and I’m still upset about it - Mozilla also has a marketing department - Mozilla also collects usage data in the same way that every other application with crash reporting does Using Firefox even with the defaults unchanged is still way less of a piece of spyware than Chrome with the defaults unchanged. By default Chrome integrates with your Google login tying together a stupidly huge amount of data collection across a vast network of sites including two monopolies (YouTube and Google Search). And yet somehow this non-profit organization that doesn’t own a search engine or social media service is a bad alternative.
- redbergy 6y ago> “If you stop using Firefox,”, Mozilla advocates will tell you, “Chrome will become the only real web browser”. > Yes, but isn’t it a bit too late to worry about that? And what change do individual choices make here? I don't think it's too late. Firefox exists because the same situation was happening in the late 90s/early 2000s - replace Chrome with Internet Explorer and I could believe this was written in 2002. It's a different landscape today[1], but I maintain it wasn't too late then and it isn't now - the fact that we're talking about FF almost 20 years after its first release is a testament to that. I'm not a daily FF user, but I am part of the install base. I think that diversity in the browser ecosystem is extremely important and I'm not a "Mozilla advocate". [1] I'm guessing part of the early success of FF was its support for OSX/Linux where IE had no reach and it gained them a lot of early traction/users so it isn't an apples to apples comparison with Chrome today. But, I remember the times, and many (even non-techie) people would adamantly install and switch to FF as the first action when they got a new PC/fresh Windows install - those individual choices added up to a very large user base.
- addicted 6y agoI’m kind of tired of the $2mm CEO pay that people have been complaining about. Ok, maybe you think that the current CEO hasn’t lived up to their responsibility so the pay is unearned. That may be a reasonable argument but has nothing to do with the amount the CEO is paid. The reality is that the leader of a not for profit organization competes in the same job market as those for for profit organizations. So if you want someone decent to do a good job then you need to pay them the market price. Now one thing some may point to is that occasionally the not for profit CEO is paid too much even relative to the for profit CEO. But this is misleading because for profit CEOs get paid in many other ways. Stock options, bonuses, promises of future profits, buying them a place to stay, an airplane, etc. Now, there is a different argument that CEOs in the US overall are paid too much. But that’s a wholly different issue that needs to be resolved at a macro level and cannot be resolved at an individual organization level.
- leetcrew 6y ago> The reality is that the leader of a not for profit organization competes in the same job market as those for for profit organizations. So if you want someone decent to do a good job then you need to pay them the market price. I'm not sure how true this is. people that work at non-profits often don't view jobs at for-profits as acceptable substitutes unless they really need the money. the belief that they are making the world a better place (or at least the image of doing so) is part of the compensation package. the real bidding war is among other non-profits.
- elcritch 6y agoA good example of what your saying is Jimmy Whales. He claims to have taken no salary from Wikimedia [1], despite running one of the top internet sites by traffic. Wikipedia makes a fair chunk in donations, but none of their execs make more than about $200k or $300k, IIRC. If anything, a top exec making $2 million at a tech non-profit might be actively attracting the wrong leadership to run Mozilla. Same with the other top execs. If Firefox share was increasing, perhaps you'd have a case otherwise. I kinda hope someone creates a viable Firefox fork and backing org, with better stewardship as I've long been a Firefox fan. 1: https://twitter.com/jimmy_wales/status/1118168799876976640?lang=en https://twitter.com/jimmy_wales/status/1118168799876976640?l...
- danShumway 6y agoThis article is fatalistic and harmful, and I have zero patience for it. I understand that it's become fashionable to say that there's really no difference between Mozilla and Google, and that Mozilla has fallen from its ideals and become an awful, abusive company. And I'm not going to debate over whether or not Mozilla is a great company, people can indulge in whatever hot takes they want. But even if I agreed that Mozilla was completely unfixable, this article would still be terrible. It's not offering any solutions, it's not adding anything to the conversation, it's not serving any purpose other than to put down people who are trying to make the web better. ---- A quick TLDR of the article's main points: - Firefox makes design decisions I don't like, which is emotional abuse, and therefore I've decided to switch to a Chromium fork, because Google will definitely make fewer design decisions I don't like without consulting me. - Firefox includes Google Analytics, so there's no practical difference between it and Chrome, a browser that links Google sign-in to your browser account and doesn't respect settings to automatically clear cookies for Google domains. - Do you remember web extensions vs XUL? We're still having this conversation, and we will always have this conversation until the end of time, even though pretty much every serious security researcher at this point agrees that extension sandboxing is necessary to protect end users. - Also, telling people to try to solve problems as individuals or to collectively take control of their computing experience is also emotional abuse. This comparison has no problematic implications at all. It was definitely the right analogy for me to use. - Sure we can try to fix this stuff, but would losing adblockers really be that bad? I mean, yes, but... think about it. Let's pretend for a second that adblockers are losing the battle, and that they aren't growing in usage every single day, and that browser crackdowns and increased DRM aren't a direct response to one of the largest modern success stories in the battle against pervasive advertising. Let's pretend there aren't any additional gains to be had in this area, and that actually it's headed for an inevitable decline. - The web is headed in a bad direction right now, to the point where a complete rework might be necessary to change things, and I've decided that accelerationism is an appropriate response. Normal users don't care about any of this, and I haven't thought about what that might imply about the feasibility of a community-run, radical restructure of how the web works. Google is going to do whatever it wants to do, even if people try to oppose them, and I haven't thought about what that might imply about the feasibility of convincing Google to rebuild their own vision of the web that isn't a trash pile. - A neocities website told me that UnGoogled Chromium is the safe option now, and I haven't looked into the addon/privacy features of Firefox past that to figure out if the website actually understands what it's talking about. The only thing that matters here for privacy is what requests the browser makes when it starts up -- not container isolation, anti-fingerprinting, or better adblocking APIs. I also see no irony in recommending people compile their own fork to avoid reading a small config guide that shows how to disable anti-privacy features in Firefox. - "the future doesn't look bright, but we are past the point of no return". ---- There's a more reasoned, less sarcastic response possible about how most of the people who say the web is irredeemably bad aren't really paying much attention, and aren't involved enough in web conversations to realize how bad the world could be and what the web currently enables. But someone else will need to write it and dig up the examples. I'm being kind of mean here, maybe too mean, but that's because I feel very angry reading this. If the author wants to go sulk off someplace and talk about how nothing matters because individuals and communities can't change the direction of the world, then go do that. But stop dragging other people down to that level. I am not willing to give up on one of the only remaining mass-market Open computing platforms. I will go kicking and screaming into that night. And I will work with any company to pragmatically make the web better, even if they don't fit anyone else's ideals of what a perfect company is. Even if they have structural problems like Mozilla.
- vezycash 6y agoThe "we made this decision based on user feedback" part reminds me of Microsoft. Their drastic ui change made me stop using Firefox on android. It now requires a phd in computer science to figure out how to a website to the speed dial page.
- dralley 6y ago> It now requires a phd in computer science to figure out how to a website to the speed dial page. https://imgur.com/a/7pZ6tbn https://imgur.com/a/7pZ6tbn I'm gonna say that no, this does not exactly require a PhD to pull off. It's right there in the main menu. 2 clicks.
- vaccinator 6y agoRoll back to fennec v68
- dralley 6y ago> Mozilla seems to disagree, as the Megabar change has shown. Not only have they introduced a meaningless but annoying change, but they actively want to prevent people from disabling it. The reason they rewrote the URL bar code was that the previous version was written using XUL / XBL, and they are in the process of removing XUL / XBL from the browser. Writing a new version while leaving the old version around would defeat the entire purpose, which was deleting the old code to reduce technical debt. Now, my personal preference would have been that they rewrite it without re-designing it - but "actively prevent people from disabling it" is a very inaccurate description of what happened.
- SimeVidas 6y agoThis sounds like a bunch of ”but her emails” to me. Mozilla and Apple are the only two companies that can realistically oppose Google’s egocentric vision of the web and prevent the web from effectively becoming Google’s platform. Simple as that. Excuse my language, but I don’t give a flying fuck about Mozilla’s “issues” and the “abuse” I’m supposedly enduring. I want Mozilla to oppose Google, and as far as I can see, Mozilla is doing that.
- klyrs 6y agoThey're really not opposing google. By default, they send google every keypress in the address bar. They've also integrated google analytics to a degree that I'm quite uncomfortable with. So I kinda agree with you in principal, but in practice, they get a ton of money from Google; their CEO in particular gets a ton of money from Google, and it shows in the decisions that they've made.
- SimeVidas 6y agoMozilla opposes Google by taking a stand against some of the APIs that are shipping in Chrome: https://mozilla.github.io/standards-positions/ https://mozilla.github.io/standards-positions/.
- PaulHoule 6y agoThe problems that he describes as "abusive" are structural to the "non-government organization" or "non-profit organization". People have similar concerns with Oxfam and the United Way, just to name a few. (e.g. I can think about the local chairperson of the United Way as a 'good person' but decide to give the the community in other ways) As Mozilla goes specifically, they have a nice headquarters which is separated by the longest 30 miles of Interstate Highway in America from their chief competitor. They get to share "expert networks" with Google, but they will inevitably be out of touch with the rest of the world in the exact same way Google is out of touch with the rest of the world. The trouble is Google has the profit motive to give it some clarity but Mozilla doesn't. Without deep roots in the rest of the world, Mozilla can't exploit markets that are defensible from Google. One could spin some scenarios where they were based in (say) Dublin, or Frankfurt, Philadelphia, Salt Lake City, or some combination of tier-2 cities worldwide however and still face the problem that the consumer voice is hard for a non-profit to hear. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exit,_Voice,_and_Loyalty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exit,_Voice,_and_Loyalty
- ubercow13 6y agoNot everyone is forcing themselves to use Firefox for ideological reasons that make the relationship abusive. I just use it because I think it's a better browser. The idea that its only worth is political or idelogical is strange to me.
- moron4hire 6y agoI understand why people don't want to use Google Chrome, and I agree with them completely. But I don't get why people want to use Firefox. Not today, at least. Firefox came out in 2002, when Internet Explorer had 90% of the market share. It would take 8 years for Firefox's popularity to peak, capturing about 1/3rd of the market, still leaving about 50% to IE. 2010 was also about a year after the first release of Google Chrome. It's been a downward slide ever since then. Chrome passed it within 2 years. In another 2 years, Chrome passed IE. Now, Firefox currently sits at 4%. 4% of the market, and yet the bug reports I get on my open source projects are almost all from Firefox users. They are issues of Firefox not implementing the full spec of one Web standard or another. (Oh, and the reporters are usually not particularly nice about it, either). One might argue the particular parts that aren't implemented haven't completed the standardization process. That is true, for many APIs. But it's a ridiculous state of affairs. A lot of these APIs have been locked up in the standardization process for years. For example, WebRTC took nearly 8 years to get a finalized standard. The reason for this foot-dragging? "Lack of consensus on implementations". It has been Mozilla's inability to compete that has held the Web back. I run headlong into issues with Firefox nearly every day that have a BugZilla ticket attached that dates back 5, sometimes 10 years. Often, the answer to why it's not been fixed: "this is really hard". Well, if you had started, maybe you'd be done by now. As a long-time web developer, having lived through the death of Netscape, the dominance of IE, the rise of Chromium, I understand the importance of having multiple, competing browser vendors. We need diversity. We need competition. Standards are supposed to make that possible. Mozilla is not giving it to us. People say that the Chromium hegemony is going to hold the Web back. I think it's Mozilla, failing to be good stewards of their products, that is holding the Web back.
- mariusor 6y agoSorry for the snark but you seem to be a bird in a golden cage. > Oh, and the reporters are usually not particularly nice about it, either > Well, if you had started, maybe you'd be done by now. I know HN is not a bug report, but this seems a little heavy on the irony.