4 ms·
> The best antidote for bad ideas and conspiracy theories is transparency and public debate. I've been on the internet for decades. I fully disagree with this
by dragontamer 6y ago
> The best antidote for bad ideas and conspiracy theories is transparency and public debate.
I've been on the internet for decades. I fully disagree with this. EDIT: Mass bannings, aka an "Exodus Event", was the solution to almost all major conspiracies I've witnessed.
1. When GameFAQs LUEsers gained conspiracy theories against the website and other reckless behavior, to the point of harming the website, the solution was to cut off LUE and prevent the public from viewing that message board.
2. I never visited SomethingAwful, but clearly the toxic subset of that community was banned and eventually moved to 4chan.
3. 4Chan's prominence in the late 00s / early 10s was clearly toxic and always was. 4chan was just focused on hitting "safe" targets, such as harassing Scientology / Scientologists. As soon as 4chan's toxic behavior was unleashed to more mainstream ideas, it was clear that the toxicity had to be stopped, and 4chan moderators stepped up their game.
4. 8Chan was created in response to the Gamergate conspiracies, as was some legitimate sites like Resetera (though they took the less conspiracy-minded side).
----------
For the most part, the bannings on 4Chan worked. We don't see Gamergaters pushing their silly conspiracy theories today, or other vile attacks on people. Furthermore, the doxing / swatting mostly stopped on that subject.
> This move will serve to push these movements underground to Tor or other uncensorable networks where they're even harder to monitor.
Yes, that's called an exodus. But as various websites gain prominence, they discover again-and-again that with prominence comes responsibility.
When you have a group of doxers and swatters visiting your website, you start to punish that subgroup. That's just what must happen. Yeah, its a temporary fix (doxers / swatters will move elsewhere), but at a minimum, it sends the message that such behavior won't be tolerated.
> It also sends a message to them that they're on to something (because if the QAnon conspiracy was real, the "deep state" would indeed try to snuff it out).
Tell me: when a child is misbehaving and thinks "Adults are out to get me", do you go more lenient on them?
EDIT: Adults are just like children: you have to punish bad behavior and reward good behavior. That's just the basis of building a modern society.
- 0xy 6y agoThere's 9 hits for the hard-R N-word on 4chan's /pol/ board right now. >We don't see Gamergaters pushing their silly conspiracy theories today According to a 4chan archive site, there have been 4,845 mentions of "gamergate" this year alone. So that's absolutely false.
- rangibaby 6y agoOnly 9 basically proves OPs point. I haven’t been near 4chan for over a decade but it was more like 9 times per post back in the day(a slight exaggeration)
- dragontamer 6y ago> According to a 4chan archive site, there have been 4,845 mentions of "gamergate" this year alone. So that's absolutely false. At the height of the Gamergate conspiracy, there were constant Doxxing and Swatting of game journalists. That behavior (knock on wood) seems to have stopped. MOOT publicly condemning the practice made a huge difference. It set lines in the sand, and people do trust their leaders. (And yes, 4chan's leader at the time was MOOT).
- srtjstjsj 6y ago*moot
- 3np 6y agoThere's a very significant difference between website operators moderating content and banning users, versus coercing ISPs to block access to those sites or revoking ownership of IP numbers or DNS names.
- dragontamer 6y agoThe issue being raised is that the 8chan IPs here are owned by nobody. > Both the Nevada-based web hosting company owned by 8chan’s current figurehead and the California firm that provides its sole connection to the Internet are defunct businesses in the eyes of their respective state regulators. > In practical terms, what this means is that the legal contracts which granted these companies temporary control over large swaths of Internet address space are now null and void, and American Internet regulators would be well within their rights to cancel those contracts and reclaim the space.
- bitdizzy 6y agoGoodness! Someone else who remembers LUE. It's refreshing that someone else has noticed the repetitive cycle of the Internet. There were white supremacists taking advantage of usenet from the beginning. "Sunlight is the best disinfectant" is useless pablum to someone like me who has seen the same people acting in bad faith pushing the most pernicious ideas on each communication platform that comes and goes for decades.
- njharman 6y agoSo, the banning worked. There is no opinions you don't like on the internet anymore? And all the reporting and exposure from protesters and activists, and portrayals in media aka sunshine. Hasn't reduced racism and gender bigotry over last 50 years. I've been alive 50 years. Everything is better now than in the 70s 80s or 90s. There are louder fringers, amplified by internet et al. But, society at large has, is, and will continue to progress to less bigotry.
- dragontamer 6y ago> So, the banning worked. There is no opinions you don't like on the internet anymore? The "exodus" events were never about silencing __opinions__. They were about destroying __actions__. In the case of 4chan and Gamergate, the Gamergaters were constantly Doxxing people and Swatting people online. Because these doxxing events and swatting events have mostly stopped, I can absolutely say that it was a success. ----- In the case of GameFAQs LUEsers, it was a matter of "mods are asleep, post pornography" on child-friendly sections of the site (Like Pokemon and whatnot). Large scale coordinated efforts to troll and harass. That behavior largely stopped once LUE was silenced. Everyone agreed that free-speech was important, but not when that speech was used to disrupt and destroy the community. (IE: Coordinating widespread trolling efforts). Twitter, Facebook, and other mainstream sites are finally coming to terms with this reality. Heck, even Reddit had its exodus events when it banned /r/TheFappening, /r/jailbait, /r/WatchPeopleDie, /r/CreepShots, and other groups. Everyone is for freedom of speech, but the line is drawn at obviously abusive behavior. And guess what? Banning those communities works. People stopped making /r/CreepShots when the community was banned. ------ Success? Yes. In every instance. Limited albeit: it forced the trolls and /r/CreepShot groups off the site and into worser corners of the internet. But it absolutely curtailed the growth of these communities. Its a limited success, but one that has clearly worked. More so than naïve hopes of "engaging in debate" with these deplorables. Debate works on reasonable people. But when people decide to be unreasonable, you must enact stricter actions. An exodus event should never be taken lightly, and should only be used as a last resort. The new webmasters would accept the nomadic group (ie: LUEsers went to Something Awful IIRC), but when their toxic behavior became apparent, the exodus continued (ie: to 4Chan, and then finally to 8chan today). I'm no "internet historian": there are other people who have far better understanding of how these groups moved about. But from my casual perspective, the pattern of "harass -> banning -> exodus to new website -> harassment -> banning" is cyclical and almost predictable. -------- Under no circumstances have I ever seen "debate" actually work to fix the poor behavior of a group. Absolutely never. Period. When a group has reached "critical trolling mass", its no longer about debate, but about harassment, and online intimidation. When you move in to try to engage in a friendly debate, they'll work to release your IP address, your phone number, your Facebook accounts... and harass you in the real world (and may even start Swatting you).