3 ms·
While I don't object to the outcome here, the process to collect this VAT in my opinion was wrong. It looks like Uber decided they'd found a loophole in the VA
by londons_explore 6y ago
While I don't object to the outcome here, the process to collect this VAT in my opinion was wrong.
It looks like Uber decided they'd found a loophole in the VAT law. The government reviewed it and agreed. A random third party (the goodlaw project) forced the government to reconsider and collect the tax retrospectively.
I don't want to live in a world where a random third party can 'telltale' on me to the government after I've already been given the go-ahead.
In my mind, the correct route for this should be that the third party asks the government to clarify the law, and then Uber is forced to pay VAT from that point forward.
- user5994461 6y agoThe process is wrong in that HRMC should be doing its job without having people pushing it to. I however refuse to give credit to Uber for finding loopholes and trying to get some pseudo approval to use them. They know very well that they operating on the edge on the law and it might come back to bite them.
- londons_explore 6y ago> The process is wrong in that HRMC should be doing its job without having people pushing it to. Sure, but when they fail to do their job, any retrospective adjustments should be in favour of the taxpayer not the government. Imagine if a policeman stopped and searched your car (legally), and then later came round to your house saying "I didn't have my glasses on, so didn't search well enough. I want to search again".
- srtjstjsj 6y agoI don't understand what's wrong with doing a job completely instead of giving up halfway through.
- tolien 6y ago> Imagine if a policeman stopped and searched your car (legally), and then later came round to your house saying "I didn't have my glasses on, so didn't search well enough. I want to search again". Your analogy is invalid, though, because Uber made a legal declaration as part of their VAT return which was based on (at best) an untested interpretation of the law. Their original accounts weren’t the product of a search by HMRC that was incomplete, Uber gave them numbers which were later found to be wrong and asserted (under all the penalties associated with false tax declarations) that they were correct. A better analogy would be if you told a police officer that there weren’t any bodies in the boot of your car, but when they later looked (following a report from a passer-by) you had a collection of severed heads sitting in the back seat.
- benjaminjosephw 6y agoThe UK Government can't decide directly how the law is applied - that is up to the courts. Getting a decision like this is a way for laws to be clarified since it sets a precedent around how the law should be interpreted. The "third party" here is a not-for-profit seeking to challenge injustice for the sake of the public good. HMRC failing to apply the law fairly is definitely an issue that affects the public and if it takes a third party like this to represent the people where the state has failed, more power to them! For VAT there are time-limits for corrections. I believe it's 4 years for a mistake and 20 years where there are "deliberate inaccuracies". Both seem like very sensible timelines in relation to business risk. If you're at the edge of the law, you're going to carry a lot more risk so it might be worth following the spirit, not just the letter, of the law. It is fair to say that this is a complex case though. It's unclear whether Uber truly is a platform or a service just as it's unclear whether its "staff" are contractors or employees. I think it's right that these definitions are grappled with by civil society. Where else should disagreements about these definitions take place if not in open court?