5 ms·
"Taking money from someone else kills more start-ups than anything else does." Overfunding does kill some startups, but it's an exaggeration to call it the num
by pg 18y ago
"Taking money from someone else kills more start-ups than anything else does."
Overfunding does kill some startups, but it's an exaggeration to call it the number 1 cause of death. What kills the most startups is building lame products.
- tptacek 18y agoOverfunding is what causes lots of companies to build lame products.
- pg 18y agoNot lots. Only a tiny fraction of startups have the luxury of being overfunded. Most are underfunded. And poor startups produce lame products at at least the rate that rich ones do. Therefore overfunding is responsible for at most a tiny fraction of lame products.
- tptacek 18y agoThat might be true in consumer web products. I wouldn't know. But it's wrong in enterprise IT products. Venture funding pushes people towards rube goldberg contraptions that overcome "defensibility" hurdles by sounding unlike anything else on the market and, not coincidentally, unlike anything anyone would want to buy. You want a good example? Procket.
- shawndrost 18y agoIn enterprise IT, the buyer isn't the user, and purchasing decisions are based on many factors besides quality of the software. It's unrealistic to blame all of that on VC funding.
- tptacek 18y agoThis is a myth about enterprise IT products. I'm calling the whole space "enterprise", because that's what Graham would call it, but we're talking about all products that sell for over the ~$60k to justify direct sales. That may include crazy stuff like SAP or PeopleSoft --- ew --- but it also includes Splunk and Palo Alto Networks and pretty much every security products. The buyer is the user for almost all of these products. Quality is very much an issue, although it's again stunted by VC.
- cperciva 18y agoOverfunding does kill some startups, but it's an exaggeration to call it the number 1 cause of death. What kills the most startups is building lame products. I think their point is that those factors are related. If someone gives you a huge pile of cash, there's a temptation to answer any criticism with "you think it's lame now, but just wait -- once we're done you'll love it". If you don't have a lot of money, you can't use that excuse -- you have to build something which people want from the start.
- tptacek 18y agoVC will also often refuse to allow you to build simple products, or products that already exist in the market, or to go to market with a product that does not have a hockey stick projection behind it.
- webwright 18y agoin a settting like 37s is talking about, funding probably means seed/angel funding. How much control/influence do you think these types of investors have? They have a minority stake, rarely have a board seat, etc. It's easy/popular to blame bad products on investors, but usually that's pretty unfair. I think (at the seed stage) it's usually due to the founders. I think better advice might be "don't take so much money that you have to give up early control." It seems to me that a well-run angel funded startup will get to market quicker and have a slightly bigger (and potentially quicker) exit if the founders play their cards right. So you trade a small minority stake for getting "there" (wherever there is) months or years sooner as well as having a slightly better shot at a win due to investor influence. This all assumes a goal of eventual liquidity, of course.
- fallentimes 18y agoDid Rescuetime take angel funding?
- tptacek 18y agoYC.
- jkent 18y agoWhat about lame people as the most common reason for failure (who also build lame products, with lame execution) ?