Err, my bad. I initially quoted a lot more and then trimmed it down, but deleted the wrong part. Let me try again: >From Todhunter's biography [9] we learn tha

Err, my bad. I initially quoted a lot more and then trimmed it down, but deleted the wrong part. Let me try again: >From Todhunter's biography [9] we learn that the reviewer was William Whewell, F.R.S. Whewell wrote: > >[...] > >/Philosophers/ was felt to be too wide and too lofty a term, and was very properly forbidden them by Mr. Coleridge, both in his capacity of philologer and metaphysician; /sarans/ was rather assuming, besides being French instead of English; some ingenious gentleman [Whewell himself] proposed that, by analogy with /artist/, they might form /scientist/ [...] The "[Whewell himself]" is an interjection by Sydney Ross. As I said that entire section is cited to the Todhunter biography, so I assumed Ross had found something in the the biography that would verify that Whewell was referring to himself, but I couldn't find it myself.