3 ms·
You own the hardware, but not the software. Re-read your EULAs. The hardware is fine, you can (still) go and install Linux or maybe the open-source Darwin on i
by nine_k 6y ago
You own the hardware, but not the software. Re-read your EULAs.
The hardware is fine, you can (still) go and install Linux or maybe the open-source Darwin on it. Then you'll have the complete control, and also the complete responsibility.
The idea of iOS, and increasingly macOS, is that it's like a hosted service controlled by Apple, but on your local device. This allows for various valuable security and usability guarantees, and for an ecosystem for which commercial vendors are willing to develop software. It works exactly because much of the agency is removed from the user, and given to Apple, which has both different expertise and incentives.
I like my distro's package manager more than App Store, it gives me more freedom and a different set of choices. Most people, who are not versed well in computer internals, won't be happy to trade App Store to a package manager, and limit themselves with free software.
Freedom has a cost, and for many people the cost of a particular piece of freedom is too high.
- _qulr 6y agospiffytech: "The bigger issue is that vendors get to set whatever rules they want" nine_k: "Re-read your EULAs." Missing the original point.
- nine_k 6y agoThis is free market for you. They offer something, you accept the offer if you want. Re-read the EULAs, for you have agreed with their provisions. Would you prefer the government to set rules about what kind of access you have to have to your computer (and maybe force the evil corps give you more freedom)? That won't even be funny. Corporations at the very least are interested in keeping you as a customer. Any government, given a chance, would mandate spyware and backdoors, for your safety, but mostly for their safety. Examples abound; look at China, Turkey, Kazakhstan, etc. Please realize that the lack of agency is the principal component of the price you pay for the polish and cleanliness in the walled garden. There is no known other way to run it.
- _qulr 6y ago> This is free market for you. 2 vendors, Microsoft and Apple, have almost 100% of desktop OS market share, so no, that's not a particularly free market. > Please realize that the lack of agency is the principal component of the price you pay for the polish and cleanliness in the walled garden. There is no known other way to run it. This is completely false, because Apple has radically changed how they've operated the Mac in the past 20 years. That's my complaint. Apple keeps getting worse and worse, year after year. I was quite satisfied with the Mac years ago. In the past, the Mac was more open. Believe it or not, there was a time when code signing didn't exist, and you could modify your system however you pleased.
- nine_k 6y agoAlong these lines, I really loved Apple hardware at the times of Apple II, and Apple software at the times of HyperCard. By that time, and through 1990s, Apple was very niche, much like desktop Linux today. It did not have viruses because nobody cared to seriously write them. Apple were catering for some specific professional circles, power users who were ready to pay quite a premium for the machine. Since the iPhone revolution, Apple is about the mass consumer, with much more non-geek mindset, buying at much more affordable prices. They lock down their ecosystem both for users' security (because non-IT people have hard time understanding computer security), and to extract more money via App Store-only software installation in the future. Againx the problem with freedom is its cost, and you have fewer chances finding pockets of it where the majority is. Fringe groups have more chances to value and protect it, like OSS movement, or early Apple / Amiga / all the way to Altair customer base.
- _qulr 6y ago> By that time, and through 1990s, Apple was very niche, much like desktop Linux today. I'm not talking about the 1990s. I'm talking about, say, 2010, which wasn't that long ago.
- vageli 6y ago> In the past, the Mac was more open. Believe it or not, there was a time when code signing didn't exist, and you could modify your system however you pleased. This seems inevitable as computers become more accessible to less technical userbases. Foot-guns are fine(ish) when your user group is composed of specialists, but companies have incentive to minimize support requests.