2 ms·
I completely agree. Keep a dossier, have a trial. Doxxing is not that. Indeed I could see it even being raised as a defense against future culpability. “The
by zepto 6y ago
I completely agree.
Keep a dossier, have a trial.
Doxxing is not that. Indeed I could see it even being raised as a defense against future culpability.
“The officer was in fear for his life because he was being personally targeted by protestors.”
- anigbrowl 6y agoKeep a dossier, have a trial. When? Your approach is to limit political autonomy to zero and offer an institutional solution that will probably not be available. What if the compilation or possession of such a dossier is treated as evidence of conspiracy to commit sedition?
- zepto 6y ago“Straw man arguments are not conducive to discussion and insult the people they are directed towards.“ If compilation of a dossier is treated as evidence of a conspiracy to commit sedition, then surely doxxing would be too.
- anigbrowl 6y agoThat's not a straw man argument. Doxxing might well be used as evidence of a conspiracy to commit sedition, but by distributing the information widely it's strategically superior to holding it in isolation. It's easy to act with impunity against a lone individual, but if some unknown number of people are possession of the same information the marginal benefit of arrest is vastly reduced.
- zepto 6y ago“Your approach is to limit political autonomy to zero and offer an institutional solution that will probably not be available.” That is a straw man argument, undeniably so. It in no way represents my position. I agree with you distributing information widely is superior to holding it in isolation, and I agree with you about reducing the benefit of arrest. Nobody said anything about just one person holding all the dossiers. There are many ways to accomplish this which are not doxxing if the goal is real accountability.
- pessimizer 6y agoHow exactly do you keep a dossier on someone you can't identify?
- zepto 6y agoHow do you doxx someone you can’t identify?