4 ms·
> But when taxes are high, I see that as an incentive to hide the profits by investing in the future. That isn't really the societal win you're making it out t
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> But when taxes are high, I see that as an incentive to hide the profits by investing in the future.
That isn't really the societal win you're making it out to be though. If you "pocket" profits, i.e. pay them to investors, the investors just go out and invest them again in something else. Which is actually better, because it reduces concentration of wealth inside of corporations. Instead of one corporation growing ever larger because they have to invest internally or be subject to punitive taxes, you get many new independent companies being formed as investors seek out new opportunities for the money they receive as dividends.
The other problem is that there are many forms of investment that are taxed differently. Government bond interest typically isn't taxed. Real estate appreciation typically isn't taxed until sale, which means they can be deferred indefinitely. Investing in foreign corporations will be subject to the tax rates in those other countries. So if you increase the domestic corporate tax rate, investment moves from domestic companies to things like real estate speculation and foreign companies, which may not be desirable.
Moreover, multinational corporations arrange for profits to be declared in whichever jurisdiction has the lowest taxes, so increasing the tax rate on domestic corporations disadvantages them against multinationals that won't be paying those taxes.
- tryptophan 6y agoYes. The op assumes that malinvestment / inefficient use of capital is not a thing. You can only invest so much into a grocery store. The entire point of us having free markets is so that capital can move around. Locking it down into once place is the exact opposite of what you want to do.
- gamblor956 6y agoSo if you increase the domestic corporate tax rate, investment moves from domestic companies to things like real estate speculation and foreign companies, which may not be desirable. The reverse is actually true. Historically, the lower the tax rate, the more investment you get in real estate speculation and other passive income streams because it's now more efficient to simply not invest in productive activities when you can just get effectively free money without doing any work. The higher the tax rate, the more businesses invest in actual business activities, because they get more expenses they can use to offset income they may earn, and because passive activities generally don't generate enough of a return to be worth the investment compared to (re)investing in an actual business.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> The higher the tax rate, the more businesses invest in actual business activities, because they get more expenses they can use to offset income they may earn The purchase price of real estate is ultimately deductible as depreciation, as is mortgage interest, and any profits from rents get reinvested into buying more real estate which becomes deductible as depreciation again. Also, real estate speculation is commonly done using LLCs (passthrough, no corporate income tax anyway).
- gamblor956 6y agoLand doesn't depreciate, only structures and improvements to the land. Mortgage interest is not included in the basis of real property or in depreciation. It's just another deductible expense. Most real estate companies are partnerships or REITs due to special tax provisions. But most of their investors are corporate entities. Generally, profits from rent are not reinvested in buying more real estate because they simply aren't sufficient for that. Real estate is a cash flow game: real properties are purchased through commercial mortgages, and rental income services the debt. Generally, profits arise when real properties are sold for appreciated values. Because of this, real estate investment flourishes in low tax years: as a result of depreciation, the cost basis of the real property has been reduced, so the taxable income from the sale has increased.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Land doesn't depreciate, only structures and improvements to the land. The structures are generally the majority of the value of the property. > Mortgage interest is not included in the basis of real property or in depreciation. It's just another deductible expense. Nonetheless it's a major expense and fully deductible. They also get to deduct property maintenance etc. > Most real estate companies are partnerships or REITs due to special tax provisions. But most of their investors are corporate entities. A group of ten individuals who get together to buy an apartment complex are not a corporation. Moreover, if the investors are a corporation, it's still one less layer of indirection -- for a corporate investor, if the real estate holding company were an S Corp you would be paying corporate income tax twice. > Real estate is a cash flow game: real properties are purchased through commercial mortgages, and rental income services the debt. This is true until the debt is paid, but then isn't that the point? They get to deduct the interest and depreciation and maintenance, and wipe out their rental income. > Because of this, real estate investment flourishes in low tax years: as a result of depreciation, the cost basis of the real property has been reduced, so the taxable income from the sale has increased. That would result in real estate sales in low tax years, i.e. willingness to divest rather than willingness to invest. During the high tax years people would want to buy/hold and continue speculating to continue to defer paying the high taxes on the appreciation.