3 ms·
"Disappointment · Section VIII, at the end of the Complaint, is entitled “Request for Relief”. It doesn’t even fill one of the 64 pages... Maybe this is a sympt
by shadowgovt 6y ago
"Disappointment · Section VIII, at the end of the Complaint, is entitled “Request for Relief”. It doesn’t even fill one of the 64 pages... Maybe this is a symptom of me not being an antitrust lawyer, but I’d have hoped for some specific, creative ideas on how to accomplish these good things."
Also not a lawyer, but I listen to enough law podcasts to make a wild guess: if the lawyers ask for specific structural relief, they constrain what the judge is allowed to do. For example, let's assume they ask for Google to be broken up... If they can't build a case strong enough for that to happen, they get no relief and they wasted the case. Or if they don't ask for Google to be broken up, but they make a strong enough case that a judge could decide that's appropriate, it doesn't matter; plaintiff asked for something else, therefore plaintiff believes that something else makes them whole, therefore that's all the judge can and should do to resolve the case. Remember, the whole point of courts is to keep society humming along by exploring how people have been wronged and righting that wrong, and the plaintiff telling you something rights their wrong is a good primary source.
Asking for "Structural relief as needed to cure any anticompetitive harm" leaves it in the judge's court and grants the saddle-point of maximum potential for disruption to Google and maximum potential for some positive outcome.
- camhart 6y agoOff topic- but what podcasts would you recommend?
- willyg123 6y agoAlso interested
- shadowgovt 6y agoI've been a fan of "Opening Arguments" for awhile (https://openargs.com/ https://openargs.com/). The co-hosts are the first to clarify that Mr. Torrez is in mostly corporate patent law, so he doesn't know the entire field... But he passed the Bar, so he has a lawyer's viewpoint on topics. The most educational aspect has been their dives into the point of the law itself, i.e. the underlying theory of why we approach guilt, innocence, findings of fact, etc. the way we do.
- lalaithion 6y agoStrict Scrutiny is specifically a Supreme Court focused podcast, but in my opinion quite interesting.
- rootsudo 6y agoYour post was excellent. Thanks!
- stingraycharles 6y agoIn other words, ask to fix the problem, not implement a specific solution. Because in the end, fixing the problem is all that matters.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoIf the team people dedicated to studying the problem think that the judge thrown at the case will single-handedly decide better relief than they could even brainstorm, they mustn't be very good at studying the case at all. What happens when the plaintiffs have 5 secret ideas in mind and the judge comes up with the worst one in his independent process? How often has a judge given a longer sentence or larger layout than a plaintiff asked for?