4 ms·
FTA: “Citroën expects that almost half of the drivers will be younger than 18. They argue that parents will prefer to have their teenage children race around th
by Someone 6y ago
FTA: “Citroën expects that almost half of the drivers will be younger than 18. They argue that parents will prefer to have their teenage children race around the city in a vehicle that is much safer than scooters or bicycles. […]
So What Is The Problem?”
The problem is that it will move teenagers out of bicycles, scooters, and public transport, thus making roads busier. That’s not where we should want to go if we want to make city centers more livable.
- burlesona 6y ago^ this is an excellent short summary of the article.
- lm28469 6y agoThis is always the same rebound/stacking problem with tech. Look at 5G, supposedly it uses less energy per byte than 4g, but we'll have 2 problems: - rebound: faster bandwidth = people will consume more bytes = need more energy - stack: 5G will be deployed on top of 4g which is deployed on top of 3g which is deployed on top of 2g which is still operational in many places. It goes the same for transportation. If an electric car replaces a ICE car it's a net positive (or maybe not, you'd have to study the whole cycle from lithium mining to end of life disposal). If an electric car replaces a pedestrian or a bicycle it's a net negative no matter how you look at it.
- extropy 6y agoTo be fair 2g is being turned down already with 3g to follow around 2022. They are wasteful in terms of needed frequency/power vs bandwidth.
- mrpopo 6y ago> or maybe not, you'd have to study the whole cycle from lithium mining to end of life disposal It also depends on the electric mix, but an electric car will almost always be a net positive over its lifetime, due to its much better power-to-wheels efficiency (70-80% instead of 20-40% for ICE). That's 2 to 4 times energy saved! (depending on model) But overall efficiency needs to take into account the weight too. A Tesla Model X is 2.5t. If your car is 2 times the weight of your old car, say good bye to your efficiency gains. That's where a Citroën AMI has potential, IMO. A really light-weight, really efficient electric car that does the job. Hope they start advertising it like that.
- fakedang 6y agoExcept they're advertising it as something to replace cyclists and pedestrians. Streets should not be designed keeping cars in mind, but keep pedestrians first and then cyclists. I for one hope it doesn't take off, just for this sole reason, even though I liked the quirkiness of the design.
- theodric 6y agoSo throttled 5G, and decom old infra
- CraigJPerry 6y ago"The roads are busier with near silent, zero tailpipe emission vehicles now" Seems like a nicer problem to wrestle with than "We have a bunch of young people injured or dead on bicycles or as pedestrians each year" Like, there's not even any contest as to which of those problems i'd rather face. If i was to uncharitably re-frame your argument, it's simply pulling up the ladder to avoid future generations having an option to take up a new form of mobility.
- pmontra 6y agoThey might replace bicycles and scooters but not pedestrians. The distances done by car and by foot are different, at least in Europe. However anecdotally I have two friends whose teenager children had accidents with cars like that and zero who had accidents with bicycles. Anecdotally my score is 1-1 (with a "real" car.)
- KozmoNau7 6y ago> "We have a bunch of young people injured or dead on bicycles or as pedestrians each year" That is because of too many cars on the streets. We cannot solve that by adding more cars to the streets, electric or not.
- EL_Loco 6y agoSo if I'm run over by a car then part of it is my fault for not buying a car and choosing to walk instead?
- megablast 6y agoExactly. If everyone just drive huge suvs all the time, there would be no pedestrian or cyclist deaths. This is genius.
- Gys 6y agoI do not know about France, but in Portugal there are many teenagers that drive around in tiny (50 cc?) cars. Those 'cars' are noisy and probably not very clean. So I hope many of them will switch to this as an alternative.
- RobinL 6y agoEven narrowly looking at congestion, the cost you rightly identify should be set against benefits. For example, what % of kids who are currently driven to school in gargantuan SUVs could drive themselves in an Ami? I would certainly rather they cycled, but i'll take fewer SUVs on the roads as a second best. As a cyclist, I'd also be happier contending with an Ami than a Range Rover, and with a bit of luck the Amis will also slow the Range Rovers down.
- nine_k 6y agoIs it even feasible cycling on some roads where SUVs abound, along with trucks? At the very least, a micro-car is more visible. Yes, we need more cycle / electric bike lanes.
- barumi 6y ago> Is it even feasible cycling on some roads where SUVs abound, along with trucks? It's feasible to cycle on any urban road where SUVs abound, provided that they have an urban speed limit. And by the way, it's not comfortable for pedestrians to contend with bicycles. At least cyclists driving on roads have to navigate drivers who had to go through training to have the privilege of being there, and risk suffering consequences if they do not abide by rules.
- analog31 6y agoDepends a lot on local conditions. In my locale, cars and bikes tend to follow different routes. Cars follow the usual fast congested main roads, while bikes thread their way through the neighborhood streets, bike paths, etc. I commute by bike to my workplace amidst very little traffic. In the downtown area, there are some bike paths and lanes that bypass the worst of the car traffic, thanks to abandoned rail lines.
- megablast 6y agoWell guarantee you every road has been cycled on, unless it’s a highway.
- clairity 6y agoyes, but smaller, less aggressive cars are better than the current situation (despite the generally-flawed 'induced demand' argument, which is more simply conceptualized as being far from the supply and demand equilibrium), and a good stepping stone toward relinquishing the hold that gas-guzzling behemoths have over our lives. but the ami is a underpowered for american cities, from the article: > "It has a top speed of 45km/h, it can do 75km on a full charge..." if it could go up to 45mph and 75mi per charge, you could replace a lot of urban cars with the ami, but as it is, it's unfortunately more directly competitive with (electric) bikes and scooters rather than errand and commuter cars. 90% of trips can be replaced by cars like the ami, particularly in cities.
- llampx 6y agoAmerica is a unique country. No other country has the (lack of) density that the US does. Let's let Citroen and its ilk figure out the solutions for the rest of the world, while the US gets its act together in terms of, say, allowing mixed-use complexes and building walkable cities. Anyway half of the US has a vendetta against the environment.
- tomcam 6y ago> Anyway half of the US has a vendetta against the environment. Citation please
- fakedang 6y agoThe prevalence of cars on US roads, and the way cities are designed keeping long distance car rides in mind rather than pedestrian walking is proof enough.
- llampx 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolling_coal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rolling_coal Does something like this exist anywhere except the US?
- clairity 6y ago
- llsf 6y agoI doubt Citroen would make a big dent in the bicycle market, especially in super dense cities like Paris. But I could see such vehicle popular with boomers living in the country side. That would provide some freedom to move around in a fairly safe (from elements, your own balance) and provide enough cargo for groceries.
- Baeocystin 6y agoThere are golf-cart communities in SoCal that do this. Within the bounds of the development, it's legal to drive what are essentially golf carts on the local roads. It is very popular with the retiree crowd.
- bborud 6y agoIf you counted golf carts as cars, what percentage of total cars would they be in California?
- Baeocystin 6y agoNo idea. I can say these developments are common enough that I knew of more than one used Japanese Kei truck importer that was making a good living off of catering to them back when I lived in SoCal.
- llsf 6y agoNot sure why I have been downvoted. My parents are french boomers, and I could totally see them buying such vehicle for their common errands. They do not live a dense city, like Paris. While they both enjoy biking, I do not see them going the cargo bike way for their groceries. They would still use a car. But they do not need a big car either. I guess time would tell if the new Citroen Ami would find its niche.
- barumi 6y ago> The problem is that it will move teenagers out of bicycles, scooters, and public transport, thus making roads busier. These kids are not zipping around in bicycles or scooters. They are either being driven around by their parents or Uber/taxi drivers in their 2-ton 6-seaters or being zipped around in taxis. These modes of transportation are not a panacea but nothing is, and mindlessly parroting "use bicycles!" does absolutely nothing to address the problem. I'm pretty sure people already know that bicycles exist for a couple of centuries now but somehow they choose not to use them in spite of the colossal cost of purchasing and maintaining a motorized vehicle. These vehicles pollute less, have a smaller footprint, are safer, are hard to steal, and are affordable. More importantly, they are real, exist today, don't require retrofitting the current system nor do they require legislation changes. Sounds like an improvement.