5 ms·
Maybe another outlook is that firefox has been captured, put in a box and fed just enough to keep it alive. on mobile the complaint says: "The six “core” apps
by m463 6y ago
Maybe another outlook is that firefox has been captured, put in a box and fed just enough to keep it alive.
on mobile the complaint says:
"The six “core” apps are Google Play, Chrome, Google’s search app, Gmail, Maps, and YouTube. Manufacturers must preinstall the core apps in a manner that prevents the consumer from deleting them, regardless of whether the consumer wants them. These preinstallation agreements cover almost all Android devices sold in the United States."
So chrome must be installed, prominently, and is not able to be deleted by the device manufacturers.
In absence of this, would device manufacturers install firefox and send them some support?
- myko 6y agoIsn't the same true of Safari? It seems most of the complaints leveled at Google around Android are as bad in the Apple ecosystem.
- sharkjacobs 6y agoIt's the preinstalled default but you've been able to remove Safari from iOS for a couple years now.
- myko 6y agoNot really, only iOS 14 allows the user to select a different browser as the default - and it does so in some severely limiting ways: - It isn't actually that browser rendering anything, it's Safari under the covers (though Chrome does replace the networking stack with its own) - Every attempt to launch a browser other than Safari requires an extra selection on the user's part to approve it. Every time.
- heavyset_go 6y agoNot only that, but other browser engines are not allowed on iOS at all. Even Firefox is just a skin over Safari's WebKit on iOS.
- scarface74 6y agoYes, but what’s not true about Apple/Safari is that Apple hasn’t raised the ire of the administration for being “unfair to conservatives”. Don’t you find it a little strange that pro-business/anti-regulation conservatives are going after “big business”?
- myko 6y agoI don't find it strange actually, it's what I expect out of the current crop of conservatives in the US. It's frightening but it is where we are.
- m463 6y agoI hope that the actions against google will also be leveled at apple as well. For example, apple has built deep linking into their browsing pipeline (allowing phone applications to snoop and intercept registered URLs). For example, if the amazon app is loaded, any web/email/imessage activity to an amazon url gets sent to the app.
- bobbylarrybobby 6y agoApple probably gets more leeway because they don’t force manufacturers to do anything — they are the manufacturer.
- webmaven 6y ago> So chrome must be installed, prominently, and is not able to be deleted by the device manufacturers. Reread the relevant section: Chrome cannot be deleted by the device's user either. Allowing users to delete "core apps" (and ensuring that doing so doesn't brick the phone) would go some way to leveling the playing field even if device makers were still required to preinstall them. It would either force many of the capabilities that have been migrated out of Android back into it, or would force releasing Play Store as open source to provide alternative implementations of those APIs. Maybe a bit of both. This would undoubtedly complicate security and permissions, but it would be worth it. There ought to be an exception, BTW: locking things down to prevent uninstallation should be acceptable in some contexts in return for restricting advertising and targeting, for example, on kids' phones.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoCore apps can be disabled, which for all practical purposes is the same as deletion. 200MB on a 16GB-128GB SD card does not make a Federal case.
- webmaven 6y agoThe UI pretty strongly warns you against disabling things that can't be uninstalled. I'm pretty sure that's the whole point of even having "disable" as an option (aside from ensuring you can reenable things when you've broken your phone). I'm a fairly savvy user, and I am uncomfortable disabling anything that isn't very obviously carrier-added adware/bloatware.
- xxpor 6y agoFWIW they can be "disabled" on my Samsung phone. Which is effectively the same thing, afaik, except I don't get the disk space back (meh)
- Liquix 6y agoWarning: if you disable this system application your phone may not function correctly. Continue? Dark pattern to scare users away from switching browsers.