11 ms·
The ‘Caspian Sea Monster’ rises from the grave
- eitland 6y agoIt is not getting back in use, kt is only being moved to a new destination: > After lying dormant for more than three decades, the Caspian Sea Monster has been on the move again. One of the most eye-catching flying machines ever built, it's completing what could be its final journey. > In July of this year after 14 hours at sea, a flotilla of three tugs and two escort vessels maneuvered slowly along the shores of the Caspian Sea to deliver their bulky special cargo to its destination, a stretch of coast near Russia's southernmost point.
- onion2k 6y agoThe second half of article lists a few new companies who are building new ground effect vehicles.
- progre 6y agoThis is the machine that William Gibson has Hubertus Bigend resurrect and fly to Iceland at the very end of Zero History
- Animats 6y agoIt should be exhibited alongside the Spruce Goose, Buran, and Stratolaunch, other huge craft which flew once or twice but were never used for anything useful.
- gorgoiler 6y agoIf you’re ever in the Rhineland, there’s a Buran glider there: https://speyer.technik-museum.de/en/spaceshuttle-buran https://speyer.technik-museum.de/en/spaceshuttle-buran Mayors — add this to the list of cool things you are able to do when your city is situated on a massive navigational river: buy up old stuff and make an awesome technical museum.
- adolph 6y agoI'm not disagreeing with you in the long run, but for now the Stratolaunch company is prepping a hypersonic vehicle to be launched from their carrier. https://twitter.com/Stratolaunch/status/1319342246186020866 https://twitter.com/Stratolaunch/status/1319342246186020866
- Yizahi 6y agoIt would fit in nicely with a Buran, it is quickly approaching it's current condition :) . Also reasons for building Buran and SM are rather similar.
- zelienople 6y agoFlying 5m from the water at 550km/h seems like it would be a hazard to shipping.
- J-dawg 6y agoEvery time these things are mentioned, I always wonder about that. Now that someone is building a modern equivalent (https://www.wigetworks.com https://www.wigetworks.com), I wonder what they are doing about avoiding collisions. Normal aircraft typically spend long periods in autopilot, whereas these things would presumably require a constantly vigilant pilot. And not just to avoid big ships, there are plenty of things floating in the ocean that could destroy one of these things: small boats, buoys, debris. The mast of a small sailing dinghy would be enough to cause a catastrophic crash. I like the idea of this kind of craft, but I can't see it working at scale.
- mapt 6y agoOn the KM, the rear engines are the ones used in flight, and they're mounted well above the ground. The front engines are more of a booster to get it airborne, but they are indeed incredibly vulnerable. You might be able to get it airborne without as much boost if you had the help of an intermediate phase of acceleration as a hydrofoil. The Orylonok uses a ski in this vein.
- kqr 6y ago> Its intended mission was to conduct lightning sea-borne attacks with the six anti-ship missiles it carried in launch tubes placed at the top of its hull. Being a hazard to shipping appears to be the purpose of it.
- HenryBemis 6y agoI assume the parent means "to crash on it", not to sink it with a missile. I will also say that at 5m from surface, good luck "seeing" it with on a radar. Also, at night and/or with mist.. you don't even see it coming.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- markdown 6y agoI wonder how the Airfish is progressing. I haven't seen an update in ages. https://www.wigetworks.com/ https://www.wigetworks.com/
- HenryBemis 6y agoI wonder if such solutions are cost effective. Unless they are marketing these services for a very limited (ultra-rich) clientele, in which, it doesn't make any sense. Why buy an airplane that you can only use over sea, and in good conditions? You can use a boat at a fraction of the cost for large numbers of people (purchase, maintenance), or a helicopter for a smaller number of people. And on planet earth we do get bad weather (even at sea level). It's not as bad as in Interstellar ("these are not mountains"), but it can certainly render this useless. Unless they target VERY SPECIFIC region (specific parts of Arab peninsula), then we are limiting the use so much that it can only survive as a niche company and not expand much.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoHelicopters don't tend to like the kinds of conditions that result in the kinds of seas that these ground effect aircraft don't like. Ground effect seaplanes could potentially fill the same niche as helicopters for the offshore oil industry (or anyone else who operates helicopters in coastal waters).
- mapt 6y agoYou need something the size of the KM or larger for the sort of waves you get on the calmest day in the Gulf of Mexico. Small ekranoplanes don't work so well in actual oceans.
- markdown 6y agoI reckon they'd be great flying in small-island states that depend heavily on tourism (inter-island travel). AFAIK they are very cheap to run, using gasoline rather than avgas/jetfuel. Think Hawaii, Fiji, the Caribbean nations, Seychelles, Maldives, etc.
- AlbertoGP 6y agoThe news a couple of months ago was that it had been accidentally stranded on that beach: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24305279 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24305279 > Today, the Ekranoplan–the only Lun ever built—lies stranded off a beach in the Caspian Sea. This summer, the craft was in the process of being towed from a nearby naval base to a museum when something appeared to have gone terribly wrong. Instead of making it to its new home, the Ekranoplan ended up stranded in shallow water, where it's drawing visitors. https://www.popularmechanics.com/military/aviation/a33808381/russia-ekranoplan-plane-boat-wrecked/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/military/aviation/a33808381... However, this article today claims that the beach was the intended destination: > "Lun" will be the star of Derbent's planned Patriot Park, a military museum and theme park that will display different sorts of Soviet and Russian military equipment. Construction of the park is expected to start later in 2020. For the time being, Lun will sit alone on the beach. Checking the famous photo article that was already linked from that article two months ago, it seems that the “something appeared to have gone terribly wrong” was just speculation by Popular Mechanics: > This summer, Russian urban explorer Lana Sator, 31, read about the ekranoplan being towed by sea to Derbent, a city in Daghestan, where it is due to be moved into a "patriotic park” and put on permanent display. https://www.rferl.org/a/photographer-sneaks-inside-the-legendary-soviet-ekranoplan/30777774.html https://www.rferl.org/a/photographer-sneaks-inside-the-legen... Derbent is on the west shore of the Caspian Sea, close to Azerbaijan: https://www.openstreetmap.org/search?query=derbent%2C%20daghestan#map=7/41.796/48.488 https://www.openstreetmap.org/search?query=derbent%2C%20dagh...
- GekkePrutser 6y agoI wonder how this was worth it. At 550km/hr it's slower than a plane and with 8 turbofans it's certainly more expensive than one. But it's certainly cool!
- avhon1 6y agoFor one thing, it was a (perhaps fanciful) new cold-war weapon intended to give the upper hand in a full-scale invasion of the U.S., so it didn't need to be particularly economical. For another, only (IIRC) two of the engines are used during cruise. The other six are only used to build up enough speed to break free of the water, and accumulate hours at a much lower rate.
- Theodores 6y agoI don't believe you are correct about a full scale invasion of the U.S. There are two reasons. The Caspian Sea is a sea and not an ocean. The waves are a fraction of the size of those in the Atlantic. If 'waves were roads' then you would need a four wheel drive equivalent of the 'sea monster' to make it an 'ocean monster'. Ground effect isn't ground effect in quite the same way if you have to fly 50m above the water instead of 5m. The other reason is that the Soviet Union did not have any realistic ambitions to invade the United States. Their thinking was much more defensive than Western Cold War thinkers were allowing their paranoia to believe.
- mapt 6y agoEkranoplanes function better the larger they get. The Caspian Sea Monster was not the endpoint of ekranoplane engineering. It deals well with ~1m wave height. For the Black Sea / Mediterranean sea or the Baltic, a larger version would be required, and for the Atlantic or Pacific, larger still. You could plausibly even fly it over Arctic sea ice fields without bergs. Boeing was throwing around proposals for a ground effect aircraft several times this large in the early 2000's, with the largest bumping up against the weight range of naval destroyers at ~5000 tonnes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_Pelican https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_Pelican
- 6y ago
- arethuza 6y agoCharlie Stross has an interesting story, Missile Gap where nuclear powered ekranoplans are used for long range exploration of "Earth": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missile_Gap https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missile_Gap
- mapt 6y agoAnd it's an excellent match for this technology, because of the lower power-to-weight ratio sensitivity in ground effect.
- willvarfar 6y agoA much more technical description of the craft http://www.hisutton.com/Russian-Navy-Ekranoplan-WIG.html http://www.hisutton.com/Russian-Navy-Ekranoplan-WIG.html
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoEvery time I read about these (rather cool) devices, I wonder how they would fare in rough seas. As any sailor will tell you, it is seldom as smooth as the water that you always see in photos of these birds under flight. It's like tourism photos of Ireland, where green fields are always under clear skies.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoThat's why it's the Caspian Sea Monster and not the North Sea Monster. They don't work that well in rough seas. Think of these vehicles as floating on a layer of "thick air" above the ocean. They bounce through that air like a boat on the waves. If the layer is rough enough they will bounce more deeply into it the same way a boat will sink the bow deeper into large waves. If the sea is rough enough they go through the ground effect layer and hit the wave below. Bouncing off the waves without crashing necessitates a reduction in speed that kind of makes these vehicles useless compared to boats.
- wil421 6y agoThey said it could “fly” in up to 2 meters. I would’ve expected any size wave could topple it.
- masklinn 6y agoOthers like the orlyonok were able to fly way higher, at an efficiency cost. A big issue they all share, with all other seaplanes, is that taking off in rough seas is terrible, and very stressful on both passengers and superstructures.
- justmyname 6y agoCaspian sea monster had a static ceiling around 3000m. Just enough for a rebase to Mediterranean Sea.
- Yizahi 6y agoBadly, because uneven distance between body and surface will make it more and more unstable. It can't even turn banking properly like a plane, because outside wing will be higher from surface than inner wing. It had to make turns of gigantic radius staying horizontal during the turn. Waves will make all even worse.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoI wonder about the fuel efficiency of such a thing. Jets get to altitude as fast as they can, using a small fraction of their fuel just to take off and land. Thinner air at altitude. This thing is always 'taking off' at sea level, in the thickest air possible. Fuel efficiency has to be miserable.
- Jemm 6y agoThe noise in the cockpit from all those engines very close must have been deafening.