4 ms·
> To my surprise, a few members of my tribe were pushing back against this lawsuit. Personally I think there's plenty Google is doing that's wrong † but I'm ju
by michaelt 6y ago
> To my surprise, a few members of my tribe were pushing back against this lawsuit.
Personally I think there's plenty Google is doing that's wrong † but I'm just disappointed the antitrust complaint seems to be all about the advertising industry.
As far as I'm concerned, the online advertising industry is already doomed. The first time there was a drive-by malware installation from an advert on a reputable website, the industry's fate was sealed.
When I heard there would be antitrust action, I was hoping there would be more attention to all the other problems, so hearing it's all about competition in a dead industry is a disappointment.
† Nonexistent support, low-privacy defaults in Chrome, perpetual "oopsies" breaking firefox support, over-enthusiastic anti-spam features forcing e-mail centralisation, iOS gmail constantly "forgetting" that I didn't want to install Chrome, reCapcha and DoH and AMP and GA all having the potential to act as centralised tracking, reCapcha being deliberately slow and difficult for people who disable browser fingerprinting, opaque and capricious treatment of youtube creators and android app developers, pushing sketchy browser "features" like "signed exchange" that badly solve problems of Google's own creation...
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> I'm just disappointed the antitrust complaint seems to be all about the advertising industry The DoJ focussed on search. Specifically, Google paying for the default slot. The DoubleClick/ad business is not directly addressed. The harms in the complaint are more widely discussed than in this article.
- creddit 6y ago> in a dead industry That “dead industry” is worth many $100s of Billions. What are you on about?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zepto 6y ago† None of those would matter if Google had competition.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoBear in mind, Google is somewhere near 90% advertising revenue. There are other things Google is doing wrong, but they all exist to feed into the ad industry. Search and Chrome and Play Services and everything are about protecting their ad revenue. You may feel like ads are a dead industry, but remember that via Google's Chrome monopoly, Google can harm ad blockers (Manifest V3) and protect their ability to track and monetize users ("privacy budget"), and that their decisions as such affect the vast majority of users on the planet. Everyone else might be stripping out advertising and tracking, but as long as Google's browsers are protecting it, it'll do just fine. Breaking the back of Google's monopoly is going to take going after them in many angles, and their browser monopoly and search monopoly are very important pillars of that. But all those pillars are upholding one thing: Ads.
- actuator 6y ago> There are other things Google is doing wrong, but they all exist to feed into the ad industry. Do they now? You seem to know a lot about them. YouTube Premium, Docs, entire GCP suite etc kind of hint that they don't have the same vision about their company as you seem to have about them. > Search and Chrome and Play Services and everything are about protecting their ad revenue. I might be mistaken but reading comments on HN from googlers, I remember Chrome being a docs outcome as a better browser can support web productivity software well.
- ocdtrekkie 6y ago> I might be mistaken but reading comments on HN from googlers, I remember Chrome being a docs outcome as a better browser can support web productivity software well. A narrative Googlers might tell you, sure. But that has no historical reality. Chrome, is, of course, the brainchild of Sundar Pichai, prior to which was in charge of the Google Toolbar, a pack-in that Google paid Adobe and other companies to inject into their software installers to change the search provider on IE to Google. Chrome was developed out of a (not unfounded) fear that Microsoft would intervene and block the Google Toolbar from IE. (Microsoft hesitated solely because they themselves were pretty scared of getting hit with antitrust violations again.) The Google Toolbar, and it's direct successor, Chrome, came explicitly and exclusively out of a desire to set people's search provider to Google and to enable collecting user browsing data, which of course, leads to ads. Glowing biographies of Sundar Pichai that came out around when he became CEO all testify to this. An example is https://marketrealist.com/2019/12/a-history-of-googles-visionary-ceo-sundar-pichai/ https://marketrealist.com/2019/12/a-history-of-googles-visio...