2 ms·
other replies have pointed to costs but I just want to reiterate the last point that in our particular German case the principle behind it is the "Staatsbürger
by Barrin92 6y ago
other replies have pointed to costs but I just want to reiterate the last point that in our particular German case the principle behind it is the "Staatsbürger in Uniform" (citizen in uniform), the idea is to kind of precisely get some people into the military who wouldn't naturally want to go there, because those are the people who can provide crucial oversight over military processes, and prevent the miltary from being purely professional.
This is because serving in the military is a civic duty, not just a sort of commercial service. The military is not just supposed to be a hired group of fighters.
- fierarul 6y agoThis is a perfect explanation why many political positions could be akin jury duty. What if the mayor election would be among 4 randomly picked citizens?
- vulcan01 6y agoThe ancient Athenians used something similar to select their leaders: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sortition#Ancient_Athens https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sortition#Ancient_Athens EDIT: I remember this from a Historia Civilis video: https://youtu.be/pIgMTsQXg3Q https://youtu.be/pIgMTsQXg3Q You should watch the whole thing (it's pretty interesting) but skip to 8m00s to watch the part about sortition.
- Barrin92 6y agoI agree, what I also find very surprising about this topic is when it comes up with my American friends is that they seem so alienated by the concept. Which I find surprising, because my (admittedly somewhat limited) understanding is that the fear of established, professionalised, closed-up armies is actually a very ur-American idea, threatening peace, equality and so on. I guess the same could be applied to a lot of the over-militarised police and border agency situations that hit the news all the time. Civic oversight and less professionalisation, more popular control I always thought would be natural ideas across the pond.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> the fear of established, professionalised, closed-up armies is actually a very ur-American idea, threatening peace, equality and so on. Indeed; if you read the documents, antipathy to the concept of a standing army is a primary motivation for the second amendment.