3 ms·
I feel like it completely misses the point of clean energy. In the future your goal should really be to power those industrial plants 100%. Geothermal can do th
by dheera 6y ago
I feel like it completely misses the point of clean energy. In the future your goal should really be to power those industrial plants 100%. Geothermal can do that. It's basically free energy, and you are just redirecting the heat to do something else in the process, like whatever industrial processes they're doing, before it all gets emitted as heat anyway.
Harvesting an industrial plant's own waste heat isn't going to power the industrial plant, and thus, you still make them rely on burning some other fuel that would otherwise not have to be burned.
- hinkley 6y agoYou can only afford to do that if you manage to improve the efficiencies of those plants, which means scavenging or reusing BTUs that escape out the back end.
- pontifier 6y agoRecovering energy from industrial waste heat would still be a good idea, regardless of the source of the outside power. The only question is if there is a different strategy to improve efficiency that would have a better cost/benefit ratio. There may just be no other reasonable way to recover energy from some processes, and in that case building a heat recovery power plant is probably a good idea.
- adrianN 6y agoThere is no clean energy. There is only cleaner energy. Using less energy is always better, even if the power comes from wind and solar.
- rfrey 6y agoThere are many industries for which there is no clear path to electrification. Also: Geothermal is not free, only the fuel is free. The cost of every electron has to account for the cost of building the plant.
- dheera 6y agoI meant free in the natural sense, as in, by using geothermal energy you are not creating any more heat than would have been naturally released anyway -- you're just re-routing and extending the pathway for the same exact amount of heat to be released and getting some work done in the process. As such, in some sense, with geothermal energy there is no notion of "wasted" power as far as the environment goes. Even if you leave your heaters on unnecessarily, you're just letting the same heat out from your living room instead of letting the same amount of heat escape directly from a fumarole. The heat will have been released either way, and whether you leave your heater on or not only changes where the heat gets released from. Whereas if you were using, say, nuclear power, leaving your heaters on means that you are wasting nuclear fuel and generating heat that wouldn't have been released had you turned your heaters off.