5 ms·
US population density is hardly the issue for two reasons, first nobody wants high speed rail in Alaska. But secondly high speed rail is between cities not eve
by Retric 6y ago
US population density is hardly the issue for two reasons, first nobody wants high speed rail in Alaska. But secondly high speed rail is between cities not every little podunk town. Linking Richmond, DC, Baltimore, NYC, Boston is a single 550 mile high speed rail line, which connects over 10% of the entire Americana population.
- kortilla 6y agoSounds good. Don’t make us over in California pay for it though.
- 4ggr0 6y agoWhy not?
- kortilla 6y agoBecause we get absolutely no benefit from it. If you want to have a massive government program that primarily benefits 3-4 states, don’t force Californians to shoulder that burden. That’s what state-level taxes are for.
- 4ggr0 6y agoI'm not from the US, so I guess that's why I asked. My country tends to be a tad more social and federalistic.
- kortilla 6y agoThe US is better compared to the EU than any particular country, both in terms of size, population, and distinct governments. So this is similar to a train being proposed from Amsterdam to Copenhagen that would be paid for by all of the member countries.
- dtwest 6y agoI mentioned the Northeast Corridor because it is the most viable location to have passenger rail in the US. But even there presents some issues (which I may not have explained very well in my original post). I disagree with your assessment because American density is very different than European density. If you look at Google Earth, there is almost continuous suburban development along the entire Northeast route. In Europe, populations are clustered in smaller urban centers. High speed rail can only stop so many times and because of this, it is more difficult for the average American to get to a train station. This situation is obvious to people who have lived in suburban America but can be surprising to those who have not. Imagine driving up to an hour to a city center, finding a place to long term park your car near the station and then taking a mode of transportation that isn't significantly faster than your car would've been. Then needing to take an expensive taxi once you arrive because your destination city has a limited public transportation system. Comparing region densities at face value misses the issue, the way cities and regions are designed present unique transit challenges around the world.
- beaunative 6y agoHigh speed rail is roughly double if not triple the speed of the car speed on a speedway, let alone car speed in city. More importantly, just don't think of city as static, inanimatable object. Many american cities are created because of the rails if you remember the history, High speed rail may not create new cities, but can definitely reshape parts of the city.
- dtwest 6y agoAcela's average speed is 82 mph between NYC and Boston. 66 mph between NYC and DC. When you add the time to get to/from the stations my point makes a lot of sense. If you remember the history, many of the existing rail lines were built before the suburban explosion post WWII. To make Acela go faster, the route would need straighter track which would require buying a lot of expensive, already developed, land.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]