3 ms·
I like reductionist maths counter-proofs based on "x cannot contain y", but I try to be skeptical they apply, because it is plain real mathematicians can reason
by ggm 6y ago
I like reductionist maths counter-proofs based on "x cannot contain y", but I try to be skeptical they apply, because it is plain real mathematicians can reason about infinite things, from finite symbols, as chains of symbols. the "cannot contain" set includes things I can state, but not enumerate.
I'm skeptical about AGI anyway. The proof is unnecessary, I tend to an even more reductionist model: Our lack of understanding where intelligence is, in the brain, goes to our failure to model it. "morally" making claims "its alive" based on a lack of understanding, is a bit like chemistry by alchemy. If you don't know why, you didn't make it any more than making a baby would have.
Feynman said it better: lots of physics proofs are built on partial models of sub-atomics, which if you ask questions about become unknowables too. Its turtles-all-the-way-down stuff.
traditional reinforcement learning will probably not yield AGI, any more than any current method, based on not understanding GI, and until we understand GI, I do not believe any connectionist, or learning model will derive it.