6 ms·
I'm surprised that the waste heat is enough to drive a turbine and generate electricity! How much waste heat is that hot? Combined cycle natural gas turbines al
by epistasis 6y ago
I'm surprised that the waste heat is enough to drive a turbine and generate electricity! How much waste heat is that hot? Combined cycle natural gas turbines already do this. Natural gas combustion drives a turbine, then the "waste heat" drives a steam cycle. Even though that steam cycle is less than 50% efficient, I'm guess the wasted heat there can't be used, right?
How high of a COP would it take to make a heat pump a feasible way to make lower temperature waste heat a source? Or is this where the thermodynamics breaks down?
- colechristensen 6y agoYou won’t be able to take waste heat economically from a power plant, they’re generally designed to capture more and more heat until diminishing returns take over. There are a lot of other industrial processes though that don’t do any heat capturing. Something left out though is that you might have lower capital costs but if you try tacking a power plant on somebody else’s factory, they’re going to want a cut. Efficiency is dictated by temperature differences, you get a bigger cut for less investment when the temperature difference between heat source and environment is largest.
- brundolf 6y agoWhat if you just sold the equipment (+ setup services) to the plants directly? They could turn around and reuse the recovered energy themselves, or sell it on down the line, but there would be no coordination/mixed-incentives problem.
- sroussey 6y agoProbably best to sell a kit of a few designs, equipment, project management, and financing (avoid capital costs) that shares in income but also has contractual obligations for length of running.
- colechristensen 6y agoThen you're the one taking the cut, still an additional cost that needs to be considered when doing a comparison with digging a hole for geothermal energy.
- ashtonkem 6y agoFactories aren't in the business of generating electricity. They were already willing to throw that heat away normally, why take a bunch of capital that you could invest in the business and use it to buy equipment unrelated to your business when someone else will install and manage the waste-heat system for you and give you a 10% cut for no risk and no outlay on your end?
- rfrey 6y agoYup, we offer about 10% of electricity revenues back to the plant in exchange for the heat.
- airstrike 6y agoI once came across a plant in Quebec that was only "profitable "because it had a huge discount on the rate it paid for electricity, only to later generate electricity from their waste heat and sell it back to the government at a highly inflated rate. The government was happy to do this so that the plant wouldn't shut down and workers wouldn't lose their jobs
- floatrock 6y agoYeah, it's unclear whether those 5 and 7MW figures quoted are electricity production or just heat energy. Not to imply that "just heat energy" is useless -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/District_heating https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/District_heating is the term for using waste industrial heat to heat up homes in the surrounding areas. More common in Europe and Canada than the US I believe. Cogeneration is when the concept is used specifically by electricity plants. It's used mostly in places that have need to generate their own electricity and heating like college and hospital campuses -- by harvesting the waste heat for another localized purpose, it becomes cheaper than relying solely on the grid.
- rfrey 6y agoA gas turbine has about 25-30MW thermal in the exhaust gasses, typical is gas at 480C and 90kg/s. At those temperatures we can convert that to electricity at about 20% efficiency. We lose about a megawatt in parasitic load such as pumps.
- floatrock 6y agoThanks for clarifying and giving the conversion numbers! Something like district heating has much higher infrastructure and coordination costs, but compared to an electricity conversion of only 20%, it's interesting to think about how other applications could have potentially higher efficiencies from that same waste stream. Anyone know if there are examples of industrial parks that have been designed with waste stream "stacking" in mind? Instead of converting exhaust to electricity at 20% efficiency, could that power production waste heat be sent to something like a kiln or a chemical producer that needs heat as input?
- rfrey 6y agoAll geothermal projects in Canada will require a direct heat off-take to be viable. In fact the revenue from direct heat use will generally be more than electricity sales. The 5MW plant in Alberta I referenced was built around a proposed industrial park, with the idea being to create a district heat system that upgraded the heat in some facilities and donated it at other facilities. The best use of heat is as heat, without converting it. The problem is that heat doesn't travel very well, 5-8 km is really the practical limit before insulation costs swamp revenues. And a lot of industrial heat is too far away from a viable user of that heat. If the facility can use the heat internally their process engineers have already incorporated that (through pinch analysis etc). We have one project now where we're replacing a heat exchanger that is supplying process heat from the exhaust with a power plant, but then using the waste heat from the power plant (still 80% of it left!) to replace the process heat. Overall efficiency will be around 60%.
- dheera 6y agoI feel like it completely misses the point of clean energy. In the future your goal should really be to power those industrial plants 100%. Geothermal can do that. It's basically free energy, and you are just redirecting the heat to do something else in the process, like whatever industrial processes they're doing, before it all gets emitted as heat anyway. Harvesting an industrial plant's own waste heat isn't going to power the industrial plant, and thus, you still make them rely on burning some other fuel that would otherwise not have to be burned.
- hinkley 6y agoYou can only afford to do that if you manage to improve the efficiencies of those plants, which means scavenging or reusing BTUs that escape out the back end.
- pontifier 6y agoRecovering energy from industrial waste heat would still be a good idea, regardless of the source of the outside power. The only question is if there is a different strategy to improve efficiency that would have a better cost/benefit ratio. There may just be no other reasonable way to recover energy from some processes, and in that case building a heat recovery power plant is probably a good idea.
- adrianN 6y agoThere is no clean energy. There is only cleaner energy. Using less energy is always better, even if the power comes from wind and solar.
- rfrey 6y agoThere are many industries for which there is no clear path to electrification. Also: Geothermal is not free, only the fuel is free. The cost of every electron has to account for the cost of building the plant.
- dheera 6y agoI meant free in the natural sense, as in, by using geothermal energy you are not creating any more heat than would have been naturally released anyway -- you're just re-routing and extending the pathway for the same exact amount of heat to be released and getting some work done in the process. As such, in some sense, with geothermal energy there is no notion of "wasted" power as far as the environment goes. Even if you leave your heaters on unnecessarily, you're just letting the same heat out from your living room instead of letting the same amount of heat escape directly from a fumarole. The heat will have been released either way, and whether you leave your heater on or not only changes where the heat gets released from. Whereas if you were using, say, nuclear power, leaving your heaters on means that you are wasting nuclear fuel and generating heat that wouldn't have been released had you turned your heaters off.
- hinkley 6y agoI believe I’ve heard that a lot of plants only bother recycling heat from Material streams that are above 600F. There are so many things you could run off of even 200F, like drying systems or counterflow heat exchangers. It may be that materials and handling limitations as you go up in temps outweighs the effort to extract.
- ourlordcaffeine 6y agoThe newest CCGT plants in the UK have thermal efficiencies of over 60%
- Gravityloss 6y agoYou can run a supercritical CO2 heat engine on turbine exhaust and make electricity. GE has a product. Would be more economical if fuel or emissions were more expensive.
- lambdatronics 6y ago>How high of a COP would it take to make a heat pump a feasible way to make lower temperature waste heat a source? Or is this where the thermodynamics breaks down? Yeah, there's no free lunch. You could use the low-temperature waste heat to pre-heat the working fluid for a combustion-based system, but using a heat pump to increase the temperature will cancel out the efficiency gain from having a higher temperature for the heat engine.