4 ms·
Pay close attention to some of the provisos here. He recommends using a photo of your face as your avatar. In the next section, he talks about keeping DMs open
by DoreenMichele 6y ago
Pay close attention to some of the provisos here. He recommends using a photo of your face as your avatar. In the next section, he talks about keeping DMs open and adds "if you are a cis white male" you are probably fine.
He seems to think this detail is irrelevant for choosing an avatar. It's not even mentioned in the section on avatars.
I'm a woman. A few months back I decided to not use my face for my avatar anywhere on the internet.
So if you aren't a cis white male, let me suggest you take all of his advice with a grain of salt. It may be of zero use to you.
- steipete 6y agoAuthor here: I’m gay, not cis. But: I agree that women have it even harder - I can only share my own experience though, in the hope it’s interesting to some folks.
- juletide 6y agofyi, "cis" generally means "your gender identity = the gender you were assigned at birth", as opposed to being trans. it's possible to be gay + trans, or gay + cis, etc, but being gay doesn't describe anything about cis vs trans in-and-of-itself. (thank you for the post, by the way! i thought there were some genuinely neat little tips in there.)
- DoreenMichele 6y ago"cis white male" is a phrase quoted directly from your piece. I double-checked before posting to make sure I got it right. And double-checked again before replying here.
- amiantos 6y agoAt this point I wouldn't recommend anyone expose their face or true identity to the internet. There was a time idealistic people thought that removing anonymity from the internet would somehow make it more civilized, but bad actors (e.g. most people using the internet regularly, it seems) have proven the lack of anonymity just makes it easy for people to find new and inventive ways to harass and insult you. For all the non-cis non-white non-males out there, people don't even need an excuse to attack you anymore beyond your non-cis, non-white, non-maleness. The blog author seems to grasp tentatively toward recognizing their own privilege, but fails to mention that they have 31,000 twitter followers and, having started their own business, significant adoration from the Twitter tech crowd. I can imagine Twitter seems like a great place to be when you've been elevated by the community. Everyone looks up to you, everyone thinks what you have to say is important. Life is a lot different on the internet for people who don't have that same following. I don't think trying to curate an online persona and manage a Twitter account where you reply to everyone is a valuable use of your time when you're still trying to find a way to consistently feed yourself.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoAt this point I wouldn't recommend anyone expose their face or true identity to the internet. I don't agree with that. I can't get paid if I don't use my real name and real identity online. I don't make enough money, but the money I do make helps me survive. Women and other marginalized people are routinely told things like "On the internet, no one knows you are a dog if you don't tell them" as a way of saying "If it is a problem to admit you are a woman, don't admit it" and they fail to see how huge a problem that is. For many marginalized people, the internet is a godsend. People who are LGBTQ are often vocal in certain online spaces precisely because they can't be so vocal in person. But we do need to make clear that what works online if you aren't one of the privileged few may be very different from what works online if you are one of the privileged few and it's a bit frustrating that this post -- written by someone who is gay -- does such a poor job of highlighting that fact.
- NewOrderNow 6y agoThe idea that you can't be equally vocal seems to be a limitation that you put on yourself.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Lammy 6y agoI know this sounds flippant in a world where “SWATing” exists, but as a non-several-categories person my reflex reaction to “people don’t even need an excuse to attack you any more” is increasingly “so what?”. The overlap between “people who insult women online for fun” and “people whose opinions I value” is pretty small, after all. It’s their loss, not mine :)
- jay_kyburz 6y agoI post using my real identity as a constant reminder of how easy it can be for an anonymous identity to be linked back to me. As a result, I just don't say much of anything interesting on the internet.
- OJFord 6y ago> So if you aren't a cis white male 'cis' is such a weird/annoying term; it's like saying 'pre' instead of 'prepubescent'. (Sorry, I know that's tangential to your point, but where else will I make grammatical complaints about the discourse of social issues than HN?)
- the_jeremy 6y agoI don't see much difference between cis / cisgender and teen / teenager.
- OJFord 6y ago'teen' isn't a preposition (er, are they prepositions.. I mean 'prefixes' like 'pre', 'post', 'super', 'intra', 'inter', 'ultra', 'non', 'un', 'trans', 'cis', ... - modifier perhaps? I mean that 'teen' isn't altering 'ager' that otherwise stands alone.) - and it's not a term I'd use personally anyway, but it doesn't annoy me for that reason. The better example would be 'trans' of course, but yes it bugs me too. It's just in more common usage I suppose.
- throwaway2245 6y agoPrefixes are used in this way all the time, wherever the context is clear. some which immediately come to mind: 'mono'/'stereo', 'poly', 'bike', 'homo', 'macro', 'telly'
- OJFord 6y agoThe only ones of those that mean anything to me alone are 'bike', 'homo', and 'telly'. The latter two are abhorrent; I wouldn't use them either. 'Bike' I might rarely say, but isn't an example of this anyway. ('bi' is, and I'm aware that's used - with different meaning to 'bike' of course' - but I'd make the same comment as for 'trans'.)
- throwaway2245 6y ago
- kodah 6y agoSeems like the author thinks that protecting yourself is exclusive to non-cis, non-white, non-male folks. I guess they've had a relatively rosy experience on Twitter thus far, which is a tad mind boggling! Some of this is backed by studies I've read, and some of it is my own anecdotal experiences, so take it for what you will: Sharing your identity on the internet is dangerous. Deliberate bad actors aside, there is a whole world of people out there with varying life experiences and tribal knowledge that they use to perceive the exact same world you perceive when you consume online content in a potentially different light than you do. Though you're looking at the same thing, because of the lens of your life experiences, two things that are exactly the same can be perceived two different ways by two different observers. Sometimes this does something innocuous like making someone engage in healthy debate with someone they otherwise wouldn't. In other cases it results in a lot of assumptions that the observer may make both directly and indirectly about you and what you said. When you're out and about in the real world what stops an observer from making the very same assumptions that lead them to an outcome online is the lack of notion that they know you. An online profile, and things like pictures, establish in peoples minds the notion that they know you somehow (whether they'd like to admit it or not, their actions are influenced by this phenomenon). The author kind of touches on this phenomenon when they mention that profile picture changes can result in decreased engagement, but some studies have pointed out that it can indicate that your followers already have an unhealthy relationship with you and feel some autonomy over your life choices or at the very least your digital presence. From here you're one tweet away from being someones virtual punching bag, subject of a mob, etc... all of these things are abusive but doubly so if someone can determine real world information about you and carry that poor outcome from the digital landscape to the real world landscape. My point is that all people, on any given day, are capable of abusive behavior and unfortunately it is still on you to protect yourself from them, whether they have a history with abuse or if they just had a bad day and you were the thousandth bee sting they've felt that day. While insulating yourself from abuse online is doubly important for marginalized groups that suffer from a larger pool of deliberate bad actors than cisgender, white men we shouldn't ignore the fact that anonymity, and the concept of protecting yourself, is useful to everyone.
- dnissley 6y agoThe solution to this is really simple: Use multiple accounts. You can even have multiple "real self" accounts to help bucket different aspects of yourself that you want separate. And of course, you'll need at least one anon account that is strictly separate from all the other accounts.