4 ms·
Maybe I'm just biased by what I'm used to, (London) but the true-to-geography topography seems to me to make this way harder to read. Compare: http://content.t
by OJFord 6y ago
Maybe I'm just biased by what I'm used to, (London) but the true-to-geography topography seems to me to make this way harder to read.
Compare: http://content.tfl.gov.uk/large-print-tube-map.pdf http://content.tfl.gov.uk/large-print-tube-map.pdf
- NikolaeVarius 6y agoHow? Topographical maps let me know exactly where to start looking for a stop without having to read anything versus having a mind map of the tube and needing to scan names
- OJFord 6y agoMaybe the stop density is different, but I just don't find that an issue, you'd have to be outside of zones 1-3 to have to walk more than say 5-10min in any direction to hit a tube station. (That'd be interesting actually: heat map of how far away nearest station is from any given point.) Flip side is my knowledge of London geography is pretty appalling. (Relative to say where I grew up, not necessarily to other people. The range of local geographical knowledge is probably worse here than in NYC.)
- ghaff 6y agoMuch of Manhattan is a grid so just a little bit of knowledge about what the non-numeric avenues are, the streets that bound Central Park, etc. are pretty much all the knowledge you need between about the Village and Harlem.
- MisterTea 6y ago> Maybe I'm just biased As a life long NYer: yes, you are. NYC subway map has looked like this for pretty much its entire existence. They tried flattening it recently to "modernize" it and it was universally panned.
- mr-ron 6y agoHeres a great article about this exact topic. In short, because NYC is denser than London with more happening above ground, it was more helpful to see exactly where the stops were going to let you out, vs being easier to read. https://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/06/arts/design/the-subway-map-that-rattled-new-yorkers.html https://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/06/arts/design/the-subway-ma...
- quicklime 6y agoI feel like the geographical features of New York matter more here than they do in London. At least when I’ve visited London, I’ve gotten by with just thinking of it as a big piece of land with a (thin) river running through it. But the water in New York City separates the boroughs a lot more than the Thames does to London. You can’t easily walk across the Hudson or East River, even if you’re near a bridge. Central Park matters too. So it’s not something than should just be abstracted away.
- cwhiz 6y agoI find this type of map to be completely unusable until you know precisely which stations you are going to enter and exit. If I am a tourist in London and I'm somewhere near Hyde Park, I would find this mapper to be an utter waste. Without Google Maps I would be completely lost.
- cameronh90 6y agoThe tube map is a map of the tube system, not a general map of London. Traditionally tourists all had that London A-Z, but nowadays I guess people just rely on their phones.