4 ms·
In the HN context in particular, it's important to observe that the underlying legal philosophy of monopoly differs in European and US law. It's not just that
by shadowgovt 6y ago
In the HN context in particular, it's important to observe that the underlying legal philosophy of monopoly differs in European and US law.
It's not just that the laws are different; it's the goals of the laws. The European laws (in general) attempt to stave off competitor harm. They're historically sourced to guild protections and seek to create a situation in which companies can compete. Small players in the market are seen as inherently a good thing, regardless of whether that actually makes a better market for consumers (which it is not guaranteed to; laws protecting the existence of small book stores keep prices of books artificially high in a world of extremely inexpensive data copying and book fabrication. French book buyers are essentially paying a hidden tax to have corner book shops exist, whether or not they care if corner book shops exist).
The US lacked a similar guild history and, instead, historically experienced the threat of government overreach privileging the existence of incumbent companies over new players. The US therefore has laws crafted to protect against the major threat the US historically experienced: one company making life miserable for consumers (i.e. the Rockefeller threat, or going back further, the British East India Company threat). Neither US law nor US monopoloy philosophy traditionally care whether small-time market players can compete at all ("why should it," runs the argument, "maybe Starbucks is ubiquitous because their coffee is actually better. What's the value to the consumer of propping up bad coffee?").
It feels like 90% of arguments on HN on the topic are unaware of that philosophy gap.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoI don't think that's actually the root of the disagreement though, because the behavior of large tech companies cause both types of harm. If Google makes life difficult for competing app stores by preventing them from installing app updates on non-rooted phones while reserving that privilege to itself, that obviously harms competing app stores, but it also harms the app developers who are the customers of the app stores (and then have to pay 30% to Google for lack of any other viable alternative), and the app users who suffer when apps they'd have wanted cease to exist or have to raise prices against a monopolist extracting a 30% tax. The major disagreement, instead, seems to be from the people taking the position that a corporation can't monopolize a market by intentionally isolating it. They want to claim that Google Play doesn't have an effective monopoly for Android apps, even though it has something like 90+% of the Android app market, because the iOS app store exists, even though you can't actually use it to distribute apps to Android devices. Whether that's the case under the law is something the courts will have to decide, but the harm to consumers is transparent. It creates an insurmountable barrier to creating a major app store competitor, because a challenger would have to establish a major phone platform in order to do it, and the resulting suppression of competition gives the incumbents market power and leads to higher prices. And also prevents the two incumbent app stores from having to even compete with each other.
- shadowgovt 6y agoThe question of whether the law cares if app developers have to give up more or less money to be hosted in an app store is actually being tested right now in Epic Games v. Apple, and initial signal suggests that the law does not care (the "why" of that is unclear to me; perhaps companies aren't individual consumers?). But we're in the early stages of that lawsuit.
- xapata 6y ago> Google Play But as I understand it, that isn't the topic of the lawsuit.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoIt's the topic of the Epic lawsuit, which is the one where most of the discussions took place, because the new one is only a couple days old. But it's the same general principle here. If Google uses Android to cement Chrome's as the only browser engine, consumers are harmed because they lose access to potential competing browsers that might e.g. respect privacy more. And the fact that iOS exists doesn't much help because they're even worse -- Chrome is the default on Android but at least you can install real Firefox, whereas on iOS they're all skins over Safari. So a third party has nowhere to take hold.
- xapata 6y agoAre you arguing that both Apple and Google are bad, or that Apple's badness makes Google bad (and vice versa)? That'd be somewhat like a price fixing argument.
- d1zzy 6y agoWhy would a US tech discussion site built around a US startup investment company have such a strong representation of the European interpretation of antitrust? Genuinely curious...
- mdoms 6y agoYou know this is The Internet right?
- username90 6y agoAny global company has to deal with both European and American antitrust laws.
- Ericson2314 6y agoI thought the exclusive focus on consumer welfare came out of the last ~50 years of case law and before that US antitrust was a lot more like Europe's.