4 ms·
One key insight I found from the article is the distinction between European Commission and US approach when it comes to innovation and investment in tech. > T
by ankit219 6y ago
One key insight I found from the article is the distinction between European Commission and US approach when it comes to innovation and investment in tech.
> Third, Google will argue that its deals for Android distribution and the tying of search defaults to Google Play Services (including the Play Store) (...) but is also Google’s just reward for having invested in the creation of Android. This last argument didn’t work in front of the European Commission, but it may be more effective before a U.S. judge. The Justice Department, meanwhile, probably has the strongest case on this point: sure, Google created Android, but it also made the choice to open source it, and if its attempts to re-seize control through blatant tying aren’t illegal then it’s hard to imagine what could be.
This argument did not work with EU presumably because they look at it from the current stage perspective and hurting of choices vs just rewards for innovation. Android is open source, but very few manufacturers fork it because they are incentivized not to. There are customizations, and something better could come up if more people work on it. (slightly cheeky, but then maybe Google would not look to Apple to decide what features to add). I remember one time when Samsung was trying to create an OS for its smart TV based on android but decided against it and signed an exclusive MADA with Google years ago (and renewed in 2019 as well).
The question I have here is: what if Google decides to take android private and claim ownership? It wont be well received in the dev community, but are they even allowed to do it? What would be the repercussions of the same?
- sudosysgen 6y agoThey would only be able to do it if they get rid of any code at all that they didn't develop themselves, and then accordingly followed the rest of the licenses. I'd imagine this would be a huge clusterfuck.
- vermilingua 6y agoIs that not the whole premise of Fuscia/Zircon?
- sudosysgen 6y agoThat might very well be it, but that is very, very different from Android. If push comes to shove, I would expect most manufacturers to continue using Android instead of using Fuchsia or Zircon.
- saagarjha 6y agoFuchsia has an Android runtime, FWIW.
- sudosysgen 6y agoA lot of OSes have an Android runtime. The good thing about Android is that it's Free Software which is easily extensible, relatively easy to get good at since it's Linux based, and that risk is minimal.