3 ms·
Our field is vastly simpler than medicine. We're working on the edge of theory and practice is much, much, much messier. Cut it out with the arrogance. http:/
by oblio 6y ago
Our field is vastly simpler than medicine. We're working on the edge of theory and practice is much, much, much messier.
Cut it out with the arrogance.
http://johnsalvatier.org/blog/2017/reality-has-a-surprising-amount-of-detail http://johnsalvatier.org/blog/2017/reality-has-a-surprising-...
- boringg 6y agoAgreed. Though, to be fair, I have met my share of arrogant medical practitioners.
- nvrspyx 6y agoI'm sure, but in the case of medical practitioners, that arrogance may be borne by confidence rather than ignorance. You certainly need to be confident in your abilities if you're going to take the responsibility of someone's health in your hands.
- boringg 6y agoI don't disagree that they need to be confident in dealing with people's health. In the end arrogance born from confidence is still arrogance and I would argue (understandably unsubstantiated and difficult to quantify) that it is pervasive in the medical community.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- achillesheels 6y agoFrankly speaking, how could you judge? I am coming from a biomedical engineering advanced education from a top 10 institution, mind you. And I can tell you the lack of mathematical completeness in medicine is very alarming. It is too pharmacologically driven without a fundamental appreciation of the electrical sciences being applied, well, anywhere in their disciplines.
- oblio 6y agoWell, almost every field that's "lacking mathematical completeness" is generally more complex than those that are not lacking it. Real life is extremely fuzzy and ill-defined. Almost everything mathematical is a model and models are almost by definition, simpler than the thing they model. I'd be glad to be proven wrong within my lifetime and have someone come up with the Fundamental Laws of History, for example, fully defined from a mathematical point of view.
- achillesheels 6y agoI would claim that the mathematical models of the electrical engineering sciences which permit frequency domain convolutions empirically demonstrate “real life” is fuzzy because our sensible perceptions are bandlimited, and not because of Nature herself. We arrive at approximations because things are always in motion! And I’m in the process of writing a scientific work of human history in an evolutionary biological paradigm, justified by the linear time-invariant mechanics of dipole oscillations which are elemental to all natural phenomena.
- oblio 6y agoEven if Nature were perfectly defined, which it might well be, I'd venture to say, without any proof, of course, that its mathematical definition could still be beyond our current or even future power of comprehension.
- achillesheels 6y agoFortunately, it’s mathematical definition, were we to equate a science of Nature with a science of motion, is not. Euler’s Formula characterizes all universal phenomena in time. The important judgment to make is in understanding our observation is an effect of our brain processing, with everything reducible to discrete units of simple harmonic motion, ie quanta, in time.
- noir_lord 6y ago> Almost everything mathematical is a model and models are almost by definition, simpler than the thing they model. "The map is not the terrain" is my favourite way of getting that across.