3 ms·
I prefer the original - it tells me that 18% of all hospitalised patients are alive today where they would not have been before. Yours tells me 2/3 of them tha
by OJFord 6y ago
I prefer the original - it tells me that 18% of all hospitalised patients are alive today where they would not have been before.
Yours tells me 2/3 of them that were dying are no longer, but it puts me on edge like I might be being baited into clicking - a 2/3 drop isn't necessarily impressive, like in normal times if 0.5% of ED patients are dying, dropping by a factor of three might just be the difference between a good and bad month.
18pp is always a big chunk (~1/5) of the total, it's notable whether the starting point was 90% or 20%.
- astrophysician 6y agohmm..I see your point but I'm not sure I agree, saying 2/3 of people that otherwise would have died are no longer is tailored to the problem. E.g. if mortality rate from all covid infections went from 0.1% -> 0.001%, thats incredibly impressive and important since the mortality is now 1% of what it was, meaning 99% of deaths are being avoided but "the mortality rate went down by 0.099%" sounds small and insignificant.
- petschge 6y agoWhich is why it is good to give absolute risks before and after a change. That way you can easily compute and judge both absolute risk reductions and risk ratios.
- LudwigNagasena 6y agoThat’s because people mess up percentages and percentage points all the time.
- chrisco255 6y agoBut their odds of being hospitalized in the first place have also dropped dramatically, so their "odds of dying" dropped even further.
- jpambrun 6y agoWith the 18% figure I need to know the starting point to get the picture. It could still be 82% or all the way down to 0%. Three fold increase in survivability is more informative.