3 ms·

I'm not sure that would be a net benefit over research blogs or something like a technical report directly published by a lab/working group to be quite honest.

I'm not sure that would be a net benefit over research blogs or something like a technical report directly published by a lab/working group to be quite honest. In a few domains I've recently looked at these notes to the editor / commentary sections seem to only be pseudo-reviewed and I'd say the likelihood of an IEEE rubberstamped one pager on perpetual motion would be non-zero.

bArray 6y ago
> I'm not sure that would be a net benefit over research > blogs or something like a technical report directly > published by a lab/working group to be quite honest. I think this is kind of the problem, half of this stuff sits on a webpage somewhere completely unread and not really reference-able. > I'd say the likelihood of an IEEE rubberstamped one pager > on perpetual motion would be non-zero. I would hope that each single page would be reviewed with the same integrity as a six pager. Of course, it's not impossible crap leaks through to any conference/journal.