4 ms·
Blockchain, the Solution for Almost Nothing
- cryptica 6y agoIn my view, cryptocurrency is the only real use case for blockchain tech. It's an incredibly important use case though. It's a great store of value. Because of its scarcity, a cryptocurrency soaks up surplus currency created by banks and prevents it from being wasted on creating less-than-useless startups and jobs which harm society. It also stops surplus currency from being soaked up by corporate monopolies that are eroding our personal freedoms and society. Also, PoS and DPoS cryptocurrencies consume very little electricity and don't require specialized hardware so they store value very efficiently.
- Proven 6y ago> Because of its scarcity, a cryptocurrency soaks up surplus currency created by banks and prevents it from being wasted on creating less-than-useless startups and jobs which harm society. Cryptocurency and blockchain have soaked up and wasted billions of dollars without harming the society - only some investors were harmed. Very effective harm reduction! > Also, PoS and DPoS cryptocurrencies consume very little electricity and don't require specialized hardware so they store value very efficiently. People don't keep their savings in fiat because it's efficient, but because they more or less have to.
- smt88 6y ago> Because of its scarcity, a cryptocurrency soaks up surplus currency created by banks and prevents it from being wasted on creating less-than-useless startups and jobs which harm society. It also stops surplus currency from being soaked up by corporate monopolies that are eroding our personal freedoms and society. I've read this several times and can't make sense of it. Can you explain what "surplus currency" means and what "soaks up" means in economic terms?
- whytaka 6y agoMy read is that it's a critique against low interest rates and quantitive easing making cheap (thus unvalued/excessive - a surplus) money abundantly available to corporations and people already with money, but mostly out of hands of every day people. If everyday people however had faith in a cryptocurrency, they could ride up the asset inflation bubble with the moneyed class - thus negating the effects of wealth destruction present in this implied case of class warfare (waged by the moneyed class).
- anm89 6y agoExcess liquidity from lets say excessive monetary policy is going to makes its way into other asset classes.
- mdifrgechd 6y agoI remember being at a blockchain for government event in 2018 and one of the speakers said "anywhere you use a database now, you could use blockchain". I think this was a great example of how people missed the point of how blockchain added value to bitcoin, got excited about the wrong things, and caused the boom/bust we saw: bitcoin replaced anti-counterfeit measures with the blockchain itself, and centralized transaction processing with distributed miners. It didnt replace a database, it used a decentralized database for a new purpose. Other new ways of using blockchain have clearly not emerged, but I feel like the rollercoaster of popularity came from people completely misunderstanding how it added value to cryptocurrency and looking for the wrong kind of applications. Distributed tasks (bitcoin is uber for transaction verification) are where it's at, not a database.
- cryptica 6y agoI was skeptical about Bitcoin for a long time. I could not understand how the price kept going up every year for so many years. So I started reading everything I could about our monetary system and learned that it essentially became a ponzi scheme in 1971. Then I found out about Proof of Stake and learned that it consumes very little electricity and doesn't require specialized hardware and that's what won me over. I feel like the HN community and many people in tech are in the same boat as I was 3 years ago. 3 years ago, when I saw people buying up $20K worth of crypto, I thought that they were completely reckless and that they would lose everything. Now, I feel like crypto is the safest asset of all (same level as Gold and Silver). I think people are insane to keep more than $20K in the stock market. Given what I know now, I could not bring myself to invest even $10K of my hard-earned money in the stock market because: - I don't trust the stock broker (intermediary) to hold my shares on my behalf. What if they go bankrupt? What if they are malicious and disappear with my money? - I don't trust corporate executives to have my best interests. - I don't trust corporation revenue numbers because they are inflated by artificial currency supply and manipulation (e.g. corporations feeding off of debt-fueled shell companies to generate fake revenue). With cryptocurrency, I hold my money in my own wallet on-chain so I trust no one and I benefit from the inflation and manipulations of reserve banks and corporations without actually participating in it. ---- As a developer, the mental hurdles which were holding me back 3 years ago included: - Insane amount of electricity consumption of Bitcoin - I can now see the benefits of this in terms of added security, but for me personally (as someone who is not a billionaire), it's way overkill so I can't say that I've moved past that mental hurdle. I've heard some decent arguments about Bitcoin mostly consuming surplus or green electricity from the grid but I'd probably have to see it for myself to fully believe it. - A blockchain's scalability has hard limits. As a developer who had experience in building scalable (centralized) systems, this perplexed me a lot initially. Now, I see it as an advantage in that it will ensure decentralization by forcing people to adopt multi-blockchain interoperability solutions as they become more popular. I think that interoperable blockchains will end up forming hierarchies and you will be able to pay for stuff using any token from any blockchain within that hierarchy; different blockchain tokens will be accepted interchangeably since the historical price and volume data can be calculated from the blockchains themselves. They will all be connected together via decentralized exchanges.
- 6y ago
- nomad543 6y agoBlockchain was never intended to be a solution to several things, it was designed to be a solution to one thing and do it well. Scammers seized the oportunity to market blockchain as a solution to all your problems to profit themselves and a lot of people were fooled.
- smt88 6y ago> it was designed to be a solution to one thing and do it well What is that thing? It seems like the best application of blockchain is as a semi-decentralized, semi-anonymous token for transferring value. But it's not even really good at that. It's not liquid, it's prone to bugs and attacks, and it doesn't even seem to be that anonymous. So I'd personally argue it was designed to be a solution to one thing, and it does not do that well. > Scammers seized the oportunity to market blockchain as a solution to all your problems to profit themselves and a lot of people were fooled. So anyone who advocates blockchain for something other than cryptocurrency is a scammer? That seems a little farfetched. There are plenty of "true believers" who have completely bought into the blockchain-for-everything nonsense, and they're now using "DeFi" to rebrand because blockchain has become such an embarrassing buzzword.
- Barrin92 6y agoTo be fair you can be a scammer without necessarily being aware of it, like the hordes of MLM people who run around and actually think it's a business. has the same dynamics like the crypto world even, with it promising in a sense to create value out of nothing by just holding on long enough and spreading the gospel
- smt88 6y agoYou're absolutely right. I just think of these "unwitting scammers" as victims, because they lose money from their participation. But I admit that they could certainly be considered both scammers and victims, as the two are not mutually exclusive.
- nomad543 6y ago
- anm89 6y agoCars don't solve a majority of life's problems so by this logic they must be the solution for almost nothing. Forget the fact they are incredible at the thing they do well. Blockchain also solves very few of life's problems, but it's great for a distributed trustless currency potentially with smart contracts. If cars had gotten overhyped and someone wrongly said you should use them as money, that doesn't make them stop being good transportation.
- skitout 6y agoHe is taking the example of a bank transfer to show how bank are efficient and bitcoin is inefficient... Well is France BTC transfer are much faster than traditional bank transfer, and we are not talking about international bank transfer that could take up to a week, and require 5 or 6 banks and institutions to work together (and you have to trust each of those institution), and the cost will be mush higher than an (already expensive) BTC transaction... But Bitcoin is not really a currency used for everyday life transaction, it is more like digital gold. As such it is doing well ! He is saying we can trust bank, and as such crypto and DeFi have no use. Some people feel otherwise, for 4 different points. 1) Some bank do fail... Icelandic's bank are a big example in Europe. 2008 is another example... People did lost some money there, despite massive state intervention. 2) Government can go and take part of the money you have in your bank account. Cyprus (part of the EU, not a random third world dictatorship) is an example of it 3) Government and central bank choose the monetary policy, which has a direct impact on the value the money you get into your bank account 4) Bank "use" your money in your account the way they want, not the way you want. You have a very little say in the current banks. BTC do consume a lot of energy... But there are other ways to do transaction with a much lower environmental impact (eg lightening network) and most other leading blockchain are using or moving toward much much much more energy efficient protocol. BTC is pseudonymous, but you can use other network to do anonymous transaction if needed
- happyjack 6y agoMy favorite tweet about bitcoin all time: imagine if keeping your car idling 24/7 produced solved Sudokus you could trade for heroin https://twitter.com/theophite/status/1030225104234373121?lang=en https://twitter.com/theophite/status/1030225104234373121?lan...