3 ms·
I mean the irony is when it comes to browsers you see the general tone of HN shift to the opposite opinion when it comes to features like, RTC, USB, Bluetooth,
by Spivak 6y ago
I mean the irony is when it comes to browsers you see the general tone of HN shift to the opposite opinion when it comes to features like, RTC, USB, Bluetooth, Filesystem Access. These are all features that give users more power but it's (apparently) easier to see the downsides and how these features can and are used maliciously.
Now put yourself in the Apple's position where "an iOS app" or a "mac App" is about as trusted as a random website. Tech people have a strong culture of locally installed apps being extremely trusted but that doesn't extend to everyone. Can you imagine if websites could control your firewall?
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> I mean the irony is when it comes to browsers you see the general tone of HN shift to the opposite opinion when it comes to features like, RTC, USB, Bluetooth, Filesystem Access. I don't think it's that ironic. From my vantage point, the big tech companies specifically and consistently invoke the security arguments that are best aligned with their agendas. • We need to enforce automatic Windows 10 updates to keep your computer secure. (But also, we won't let consumers use the security-patches-only LTSC branch we offer businesses.) • You cannot install an app on your iPhone that we have not personally vetted. (As part of the vetting process, we enforce a 30% cut on all digital goods.) • We need to hide URLs in Chrome to protect users from phishing websites. (But isn't it nice how it makes AMP more seamless?) • We need to give browsers Bluetooth and USB access, because web apps are safer than random Windows executables. (But also, we can advertise inside of web apps more easily.) I could go on. The problem with all of these arguments is that they aren't wrong so much as they're selective. The iOS App Store does protect users from malware, and hiding URLs does protect users from phishing. What goes unacknowledged are the trade-offs of these decisions—some of which may themselves be bad for security.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoAlso, they lock the user in to the corporation's choices. Most of these don't even have a way to bypass them for knowledgeable users.
- tpxl 6y ago>hiding URLs does protect users from phishing Real question: how? I would expect it to be the opposite, a perfect phishing site will have the wrong URL.
- Spivak 6y agoBecause it's not really "hiding the URL" despite what all the outrage bloggers tried to make it seem. It's by default (i.e. until you tap/click it) hiding the parts of the URL that the site controls. So paypal.amazon.citibank.scamsite.biz/secure/login/trustus will just show scamsite.biz.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dumpsterdiver 6y agoMy first instinct was to distrust the hide-until-click URL bar also, but you've illustrated clearly why it's a reasonable default. It mitigates the effect of malicious websites playing URL games, and allows the browser to more accurately convey to the user where they really are.
- dumpsterdiver 6y agoTo drive your point home, paypal.amazon.citibank.scamsite.biz/secure/login/trustus will likely have a perfectly valid certificate, along with the trusted green closed-lock before the URL, implying that the site is "secure".
- wool_gather 6y agoSafari does not behave as you've described. The subdomain (for example, 'gist' in 'gist.github.com') is displayed.
- saagarjha 6y agoI suspect that Safari uses Public Suffix or similar for that.
- 6y ago
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Now put yourself in the Apple's position where "an iOS app" or a "mac App" is about as trusted as a random website. The mistake is in creating a category called "iOS app" or "mac app" and trying to fit every piece of third party code in the universe into that category. What there should be is different categories of apps with different levels of trust. Then 95% of apps can go in the totally untrusted category because they don't actually need any special privileges. Which then makes asking for a trusted privilege a red flag rather than something the user clicks through because they see it for every app they install. > Can you imagine if websites could control your firewall? Realize that this has already happened. You wanted to block DNS to untrusted servers so everything would have to use your Pi-hole? Say hello to DoH. You could block AOL Instant Messenger by blocking port 5190, good luck doing that with Facebook. The web made every protocol run over HTTPS to bypass your firewall, even if it has nothing to do with transferring hypertext. Because that's what happens when you do security wrong. It has to be usable or it gets routed around. People started blocking unknown ports by default, or blocking/mangling protocols both of the endpoints didn't want blocked or mangled, so firewalls got displaced. You don't actually want that to happen (again). You don't want the only options to be living in a cage or rooting your device with some unaudited 0-day code you got from some Russian hackers. There is value in the existence of the middle ground.
- dumpsterdiver 6y ago> Can you imagine if websites could control your firewall? Oh, they can. Cross-site scripting and request-forgery attacks aren't dead yet thanks to widespread terrible security practices :)