5 ms·
> That's not really evidence of Google blocking competition. That's evidence of phone manufacturers using their power in one market (phone sales) to extract cas
by whimsicalism 6y ago
> That's not really evidence of Google blocking competition. That's evidence of phone manufacturers using their power in one market (phone sales) to extract cash out of another (search/ads).
No, I think it is a pretty clear example of rent-seeking on Google's behalf.
> phone manufacturers using their power in one market
Who has more market power - the disparate group of phone vendors who are legally barred from coordinating on things like this or the single actor that controls the only operating system package tenable for those phone vendors to use?
- treis 6y ago>Who has more market power The ones getting paid tens billions of dollars annually seems like the obvious answer to me.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> The ones getting paid tens billions of dollars annually seems like the obvious answer to me. So what, the seller on any side of a transaction is the one who has the market power? To make it simpler: if there was one employer in the entirety of Earth and 7 billion people who wanted a job - since the employer is paying the employee, the employee would have the market power?
- treis 6y agoTo make you analogy more accurate, this single employer would be paying the employees not to work for anyone else. And in that case, yes, the employees would be the ones that have the power since they are getting money for nothing.
- arrosenberg 6y agoIt's not for nothing though - the employer is buying their productive capacity. The fact that the employer chooses to do nothing with it is entirely irrelevant. Same issue with Google - by using their market power to monopolize search power across devices and OSes, they are effectively locking out any other potential entrants. That this is being done to enhance a completely different line of business (ads) is classic anti-competitive behavior.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- stale2002 6y agoDo you know what a monopsony? Not a monopoly. A monopsony. Anti trust law prohibits both monopolies and monopsonys from engaging in anti competitive behavior. You are trying to claim that monopsonys engaging in anti-competitive behavior are not illegal, when they are.
- sudosysgen 6y agoWhat you are describing is a monopsony, they are illegal, and the employer is considered to have the most power in that relation because the employees are atomized.
- xapata 6y agoMicrosoft argued it wasn't using monopoly power, because Windows was priced lower than the profit-maximizing price a monopoly would use. The Justice Department argued that was evidence of anti-competitive behavior: Microsoft chose to deter competition with an unnaturally low price. Perhaps the argument is that Google is overpaying, and that's anti-competitive.
- mullingitover 6y agoGoogle doesn't control the OS, just the services that go with it.
- whimsicalism 6y agoYou're right - I spoke loosely. I still believe my comments apply if you consider the larger bundle that Google is offering and the terms that come with it, plus the fact that they are leveraging their capital to block competitor app stores from even appearing on the home screen or being installed.
- mullingitover 6y ago> ...they are leveraging their capital to block competitor app stores from even appearing on the home screen or being installed. If Google weren't paying manufacturers to not install other app stores, other app stores would be paying manufacturers to install them, which could result in a user experience that Google doesn't control but which users would blame Google for ("Android is slow/buggy!" when in fact it's third party software that is causing the performance issues). Their deals are arguably defensible since they don't block third party app stores entirely, just pre-installed ones. I certainly see the issues with Google parlaying their dominance in the ad market to also dominate the mobile market, but I have a feeling this will be settled with some consent decrees to put up some guardrails in the ad market. The actual harm to consumers from Google's business model is pretty vague and is passed on through marketing expenses that trickle down into product/service prices. If Google disappeared, ads would still cost money and advertising expenses likely wouldn't be drastically lower.
- sova 6y agoThere is no way to uninstall Chrome from Android, the best one can do is disable it. Smells like MSFT and IE back in the day. Which lead to what will probably be very similar hearings and results.
- mullingitover 6y agoThere's an extremely easy way to uninstall Chrome from Android, which is to never install it in the first place. You do that by using the Android open source project. There are a bunch of Android forks in the wild[1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_custom_Android_distributions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_custom_Android_distrib...
- magicalist 6y ago> No, I think it is a pretty clear example of rent-seeking on Google's behalf. If anything, rent-seeking would be the other way, but that's still a big stretch. The phone manufacturers know that searches are valuable to search engines, so they charge for it even though they're not doing anything but being a broker for their users. But while that is getting a cut (literally seeking rent), calling it "rent seeking" is a stretch, because clearly that brokering and OS space is naturally valuable and the phone companies aren't just injecting themselves into someone else's money-making process.
- whimsicalism 6y agoThe rent seeking is on the other end. Google pays off phone manufacturers to sign onerous contract preventing them from installing other app stores or displaying other options on the home screen or during the setup process -> They then collect rent from the companies that have to offer their apps on the Play Store. From wikipedia, "An example of rent-seeking in a modern economy is spending money on lobbying for government subsidies in order to be given wealth that has already been created." In this instance, the phone vendors are the politicians.
- magicalist 6y ago>> Of all the things in the tech world they chose Google paying Apple, Samsung, et.al. to be the default search engine to sue over. That's not really evidence of Google blocking competition. That's evidence of phone manufacturers using their power in one market (phone sales) to extract cash out of another (search/ads). > No, I think it is a pretty clear example of rent-seeking on Google's behalf. Not sure what conversation you're having in the above comment, but this is the one that I was responding to :)
- whimsicalism 6y agoGoogle engages in anti-competitive behavior (ie. using their capital to increase the entry barriers for other app store markets on Android), so that they can then collect rent on their app store (among other things, like search/advertising). The anti-competitive actions (paying off phone vendors) that Google takes are part of that rent-seeking behavior, just as companies that lobby politicians to increase barriers to entry so they can raise prices are engaging in rent-seeking. If you want to nit-pick and say the play store pricing is the rent-seeking and the paying off of the phone vendors is the anti-competitive behavior, I wouldn't have a huge quibble with that.
- shadowgovt 6y agoIn what configuration of rent-seeking is the sued party the one paying the rent?
- jariel 6y ago"I think it is a pretty clear example of rent-seeking on Google's behalf." It's literally the opposite: rent-seeking on the behalf of Samsung, Apple - moreover, 'rent-seeking' is not remotely illegal.