5 ms·
I don’t get why they keep buying seagates when every report they do shows they have higher fail rates? Are they just cheaper?
by Havoc 6y ago
I don’t get why they keep buying seagates when every report they do shows they have higher fail rates?
Are they just cheaper?
- theandrewbailey 6y agoI think they buy whatever their suppliers can get a hold of. They've said that they would buy HGST only, but they are too expensive.
- busterarm 6y agoYes, by around half. HGSTs are in short supply states-side right now and in high demand. Toshibas are also in limited supply here (at least the desirable helium-filled ones) and are about 2/3 between the Seagates and HGSTs. Also in their product, drive failure is okay!
- NortySpock 6y agoI am definitely finding Seagates the cheapest option at Microcenter, generally $5-$10 cheaper. Can't say I'm proud of cheaping out on storage, but that's my current price-point and haven't yet made the leap to trying to set up a properly-RAIDed NAS.
- busterarm 6y agoThe price gap of high-capacity Enterprise drives is in the hundreds (as in multiple) of dollars between the two brands.
- nucleardog 6y agoJust some recent numbers because I just replaced some drives in my home server... I grabbed 2x14TB Seagate EXOS drives for $250USD each. A 14TB WD Ultrastar looks to be a bit over $400USD each. For 25% more you can get 200% the capacity with the Seagate drives. So for 25% more I can run RAID1 and have redundancy versus a single WD Ultrastar.
- busterarm 6y agoThe HGST branded models (HC530, HC550) were around 530 two weeks ago.
- metalliqaz 6y agoi seem to remember in the past they said price and ease of procurement
- JohnJamesRambo 6y agoThank you for verbalizing a question I have always had haha.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fencepost 6y agoBackblaze's usage pattern is NOT the same as yours with 99+% certainty. Their drive conditions are also unlikely to match yours. They have a solid system set up for the installation and replacement of large numbers of drives on a regular schedule and the way they segment data would require multiple drive failures to cause data loss (I think it used to be 3 drives out of 20, but don't quote me on that). A slightly higher failure rate on a noticeably cheaper drive still works out in their favor financially without adding significant extra risk.
- atYevP 6y agoYev from Backblaze here -> Most of the comments have it. They tend to be more affordable and the failure rates aren't that much different from their counterparts. Since we account for failure with our software layer a small failure rate delta isn't a big deal and is eclipsed our cost savings which we pass on to our customers!
- 3np 6y agoHi Yev! Great to see you here. Curious if you have any impression of Toshiba's MN series? Especially the helium-sealed ones look compelling with their lower power consumption.
- atYevP 6y agoYev -> Hey there! At the moment I don't believe we have any of those in our fleet (some MD and MG but no MN) so I don't have any data on them or how they'd function in our environment at the moment!
- Havoc 6y agoThanks for explaining!
- tuananh 6y agoin comparison with WD, seagate price saving is significant?
- kalleboo 6y agoIf a drive has a 1% higher failure rate, but is 2% cheaper, it's still cheaper to buy it, and just run more of them in redundancy to cover the failure rate.