3 ms·
That shouldn’t be a shocker to you, it comes down to fairness. If you have two 30 year old males, both capable of work and one works a full time job, pay 1/3 i
by refurb 6y ago
That shouldn’t be a shocker to you, it comes down to fairness. If you have two 30 year old males, both capable of work and one works a full time job, pay 1/3 in taxes and the other guy chooses not to work and is effectively supported (in part) by the guy working, is that fair? I think most people would say no.
And I don’t think it’s unique to capitalism. Even in the Soviet Union they had “social parasites” who refused to contribute to society. Same with communal societies without a monetary system. People who can contribute but choose not to are pretty quickly pushed out.
And I see a lot of comments on HN about paying taxes as the cost of enjoying the benefits of society. Even if you ignore the unfairness of one laborer paying for another laborer to be idle (even though they can work), isn’t it unfair to society for someone to not contribute to the system they benefit so greatly from?
And I’m not even an American.
- dfxm12 6y agoIf you want to talk about what's unfair, the low-hanging fruit is the increasing income inequality between executives and typical workers [0], or the executives paying a lower rate in taxes than their secretaries [1]. 0 - https://www.epi.org/publication/ceo-compensation-2018/ https://www.epi.org/publication/ceo-compensation-2018/ 1 - https://money.cnn.com/2013/03/04/news/economy/buffett-secretary-taxes/index.html https://money.cnn.com/2013/03/04/news/economy/buffett-secret...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tenebrisalietum 6y agoIf you have two 30 year old males, both capable of work and one works a full time job because they have to and another has a 10 million dollar inheritance from his family and wouldn't know what work is if it slapped him on the face, is that fair?
- luckylion 6y agoWhy not answer their question instead of reaching for Whataboutism?
- scollet 6y agoThey are both valid hypotheticals.
- luckylion 6y agoSure, but it's not a reply, it's just babbling on, hoping that the other person will change course to discuss that issue instead. That's not a conversation and it certainly isn't an interesting conversation. It's what reddit or twitter are optimizing for.
- mLuby 6y ago> People who can contribute but choose not to are pretty quickly pushed out. "Pushed out" meaning what exactly? Shamed? Debtors' prison? Homeless? No medical care? Left to starve? Euthanized? Plenty of options, none befitting a decent society. Also, fairness (which literally everyone supports) depends greatly on framing: 1. Alice pays taxes, Bob doesn't, Bob gets free stuff from the government, so Alice is paying for Bob's selfish laziness. 2. Alice and Bob both pay 30% of their income in taxes. The government guarantees all its citizens a decent standard of living, and so gives Bob, who falls below some threshold, assistance. 3. Alice is physically and mentally healthy, so she compounds her advantages and resources. A portion of her financial gains go to the government as taxes. Bob isn't so lucky, struggles with physical or mental illness, experiences personal or family tragedies, etc. He struggles to stay financially afloat, and can't consistently accumulate a safety net to weather multiple bad outcomes. He turns to the government for help sometimes. It comes down to whether you'd rather punish the guilty and innocent alike or would rather help the downtrodden and seemingly slothful alike. I choose to be kind, but I get that it's hard to act that way if you feel threatened.
- refurb 6y agoThat's a whole lot words that don't really address my point. It's a pretty universal human belief in "contributing to the common good". Even toddlers recognize fairness. OP claimed it was some uniquely American belief. I haven't seen any evidence to support that.