3 ms·
We will need laws to forbid providers of web-based commercial services from making browsers. Google has made it abundantly obvious that control over both sector
by toyg 6y ago
We will need laws to forbid providers of web-based commercial services from making browsers. Google has made it abundantly obvious that control over both sectors is a net negative for the market.
In the same way, browser makers should be decoupled from hardware and OS manufacturers, which have a similar monopoly problem.
- lima 6y agoSo who's going to pay for browser development, then? Google bankrolled both Chrome and Firefox.
- toyg 6y agoSlowing down development of the browser will actually turn out to be a Good Thing. The breakneck speed that has seen Google pushing more and more features has effectively destroyed the ecosystem of alternatives, since nobody could keep up. And after all this, is the web so massively better than it was in 2005? Not really. We just download more and more bloated polyfill libraries. KHTML was the basis for the original webkit, and that was built basically for free.
- shadowgovt 6y ago> And after all this, is the web so massively better than it was in 2005? Not really. [citation needed], as I switch from playing arcade games in my browser on archive.org to experimenting with a WebXR-driven VR experience.
- toyg 6y agoNot “massively” better. Plus, you are paying for those videogames with your behavioral data and your non-tech relatives getting radicalised by algos.
- shadowgovt 6y agoIf you've heard news of archive.org radicalizing my non-tech relatives, let me know.
- toyg 6y agoThe mainstream doesn’t even know archive.org exists. But they are all on youtube, and Google will make sure they keep doing that, “optimizing the experience” of the browser to lead them there.
- shadowgovt 6y agoDoesn't that rule out every major browser vendor? - Google: obviously - Microsoft: is a Cloud service provider - Mozilla: VPN provider, also makes a social VR for headsets and browsers and is a cloud service provider - Apple: iCloud, App Store, and Apple TV - Brave: ad network wedded directly to the browser implementation
- toyg 6y agoMozilla can easily divest from those activities. Everybody else: yes, cutting them off is the point. To allow for real competition, browsers must be agnostic at both ends. The current field has been entirely captured by giants for anticompetitive purposes. The law should be crafted in a way that allows for commercial agreements, as long as they are between equal parties, non-exclusive in nature, and time-limited if they involve default options. This way, browser companies will not be directly dependent from any single web or OS company.
- shadowgovt 6y agoIt sounds like you just "allowed real competition" by changing the rules so that only one player, Mozilla, can play the game. Are you sure you're not just trying to rig the race so that only your favorite player can cross the finish line?
- toyg 6y agoMeh. Mozilla couldn’t be dominant if they were the only browser-focused company left on the planet, they are just terrible at steering anything and utterly wasteful. Before the search deals, they couldn’t even dominate the small backyard that is the Linux desktop. By day 2, you would have several different competitors with better tech and faster development cycles busy eating their lunch.