3 ms·
The fundamental point is that he's doing this for good reasons, beyond the trivial in issues lists of a git backed repo: he believes in what he is doing. And, h
by ggm 6y ago
The fundamental point is that he's doing this for good reasons, beyond the trivial in issues lists of a git backed repo: he believes in what he is doing. And, he's doing it in ways which cryptographers I respect relate to: its visible work and its open to critique.
I have my own kibbitz about stuff down in the weeds, I think the decision to make a cellphone/SMS identity key in the recruitment and to have one device per identity is a design issue for me and my use case, but I understand this is not a black/white thing, and there were noises made in 2019 about moving to a different model of identity, I an content to wait, but there is the vague meta-question if the ranking of this kind of idea gets exposure too: How do we know the thinking around identity and recruitment?
- baybal2 6y agoCryptography is a black, and white field. Either crypto algorithm is deemed 99.9999999999+% physically unbreakable, or anything less, and it doesn't work.
- elcomet 6y agoExcept that it's not true. Even proven mathematical algorithms can be breaked if not implemented correctly, or some side channels might be discovered along the way. It's not just black and white.
- baybal2 6y agoThis put an even more extreme emphasis on being on the paranoid side, and not leaving anything to the chance, not less.
- thu2111 6y agoThat's what you'd think. Read some advanced cryptography papers and you'll discover it's not quite that simple. There are the exotic hardness assumptions: are those mathematical problems really hard to solve or not? They aren't classical, natural problems like discrete log. Then there are the odd threat models, e.g. plenty of algorithms out there claim to be proven secure in the honest-but-curious model. Although this threat model isn't entirely naive, in the real business world "honest but curious" adversaries do appear in the imaginations of business leaders at least, but most people assume the point of cryptography is to keep you secure against arbitrarily malicious adversaries.