4 ms·
Your comment seems at odds with the current research: “the most recent studies showing heritability for IQ as high as 80%.” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/He
by zepto 6y ago
Your comment seems at odds with the current research:
“the most recent studies showing heritability for IQ as high as 80%.”
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heritability_of_IQ https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heritability_of_IQ
- bawolff 6y agoBut is IQ (beyond a minimum level) really correlated with the type of success being discussed here?
- radu_floricica 6y agoBoth brothers are software engineers, so I'd say IQ is relevant for this particular discussion thread. Whether it's relevant for the main topic... that's an interesting question. Very much so. But I don't dare speculate, and I don't have data.
- TameAntelope 6y agoHe might be of the opinion that IQ != intelligence, or that IQ is a bad measurement of intelligence.
- zepto 6y agoIt doesn’t really matter what he calls intelligence - it’s still mostly heritable: https://areomagazine.com/2020/09/02/the-nature-behind-human-potential-robert-plomins-blueprint/ https://areomagazine.com/2020/09/02/the-nature-behind-human-... Skills, accurate self-image, and cultural competence. etc, are of course a different matter. Maybe he’s talking about these things, but they aren’t the same as intelligence.
- TameAntelope 6y ago"It's still mostly heritable" -- this statement is confusing to me. If we aren't sure what we're talking about in the first place, how are we sure "it" is heritable?
- waterhouse 6y agoIf you've heard 5-10 plausible meanings for "intelligence", and every one of them is heritable, then you can be pretty sure that "intelligence" is heritable even if you're not sure which particular meaning someone is using. And the article says: "on average, psychological traits are extremely heritable, at around 50 per cent." It's hard to argue for a definition of "intelligence" that wouldn't be a psychological trait.
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> If you've heard 5-10 plausible meanings for "intelligence", and every one of them is heritable, then you can be pretty sure that "intelligence" is heritable even if you're not sure which particular meaning someone is using. What if you’ve heard definitions for intelligence that aren’t measured by IQ test scores and then someone uses IQ test scores to argue for the heritability of intelligence? > And the article says: "on average, psychological traits are extremely heritable, at around 50 per cent." It's hard to argue for a definition of "intelligence" that wouldn't be a psychological trait. Its equally hard to argue for an average of things which are not faithfully represented by numbers.
- waterhouse 6y agoI'd be skeptical of a definition of intelligence that had no correlation with IQ scores. If you managed to put forth and defend such a definition, then that could turn into a valid objection; but that would then run into the "psychological trait heritability" prior. > Its equally hard to argue for an average of things which are not faithfully represented by numbers. How do you represent, say, extroversion with numbers? It's messy and any particular measure is probably not a good one, but what people do is come up with a list of questions like "Statement: I am excited when I go to a social event full of strangers; rate your agreement from 0 (Strongly Disagree) to 4 (Strongly Agree)", and add up the numbers to create a score. It's kind of arbitrary and has a lot of "noise" in it, but on the other hand there is enough signal that it is measuring something real. If you need to turn it into a binary classification, you choose a cutoff number, which will again be semi-arbitrary and make errors, but again can be good enough to draw useful conclusions. You can then apply that measure to, say, biological siblings who were both adopted, or (best) to identical twins separated at birth vs fraternal twins separated at birth, and see if genetic similarity correlates with similarity of your measure. From that kind of data, you can get a vague idea of heritability. If the thing you're discussing isn't measured by existing tests, fine. If the thing you're discussing has a logical definition and is important, but you think there can be no tests to produce even a vague measure, then I would guess you just haven't tried very hard.