4 ms·
I’m not sure that that’s the only conclusion you can draw. Some systems choose to not handle that metadata, which often makes them a worse service but they make
by saagarjha 6y ago
I’m not sure that that’s the only conclusion you can draw. Some systems choose to not handle that metadata, which often makes them a worse service but they make that choice by looking at the landscape and choosing to not use SGX. The other plausible argument is that Signal uses SGX, which is better than nothing, but in selling it as more secure than it is they do more harm than good.
- JshWright 6y agoSome people choose not to turn their servers on at all. It makes for a worse server, but it's very secure. Security is always about tradeoffs and compromises. A system that is very, very good, but not perfect and widely used is far preferable to a system that is perfect but used by no one.
- saagarjha 6y agoRight, but in this case the choice is "should I be able to discover contacts" and some people just don't desire that feature enough.
- akerl_ 6y agoWhat’s an example of a system in this space which chooses not to handle that metadata?
- Groxx 6y agoI don't need a phone number, nor do I need to upload my contacts' phone numbers[1], in order to use Matrix. [1]: I work around this by running Signal in a work profile with no contacts. So it's... kinda sorta optional, but in practice there are many caveats and complications that make it effectively not. Certainly not when we're claiming it for average users, which is Signal's argument for using it.
- akerl_ 6y agoI’m not a Matrix user, but it seems like Matrix does in fact handle contact metadata: https://matrix.org/faq/#what-is-an-identity-server%3F https://matrix.org/faq/#what-is-an-identity-server%3F I think there’s a difference between what you’re saying, which seems to be that you personally don’t upload your contact metadata to Matrix, and what I asked / the previous commenter was describing, which is the idea that there are messaging platforms which have decided to not support storing this kind of metadata. Notably, last I looked, Signal does allow users to opt out of SGX metadata storage, though the initial implementation didn’t cleanly allow for that.
- Groxx 6y agoYou can optionally add your public identifiers to Matrix (phone, email, etc), which lets people search for you via identity providers. What Signal does is 1) require your phone number, 2) automatically upload every phone number in your contacts, and 3) send a push notification to people on Signal that have uploaded your number in the past that you have joined. It's a world of difference. And a huge breach of implied trust for multiple people I've known, who joined and immediately uninstalled when they found out a bunch of random people were notified.
- akerl_ 6y ago