3 ms·
You're missing the point of biometrics. Something you are is a form of authentication that only you can use. Your face, fingerprints, blood, retinas are all pub
by Spivak 6y ago
You're missing the point of biometrics. Something you are is a form of authentication that only you can use. Your face, fingerprints, blood, retinas are all public but try as you might you can't make another living human with the same features.
If your view of fingerprint auth is "a picture of your face is the password" then of course it sounds stupid. It's actually "a face with the correct features attached to an alive human" which is much harder to fake.
The whole point of biometric auth and all the advancements in the industry are about correctly identifying alive humans and the strength of any system that uses biometrics is directly related to that. You can say current systems aren't good enough at this yet for your personal thread models but it's real security, and beats the hell out of a 4/5 digit lock screen passcode.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoThat's trivially refutable. Fingerprints are left everywhere, and can be lifted and reproduced with common household substances (tape, glue etc). A face can be photographed, printed and presented trivially. And so far, biometrics falls far short of a 4/5 digit lock passcode. The entropy in most fingerprint sensors is a few bits. They are famously defeatable. Nothing will change the fact that you cannot keep your face and fingerprints secret, cannot/won't change them, and they are always, always traceable to you. Using them to secure a 'better' key is not security at all.
- Spivak 6y agoIt doesn't matter since your fingerprint isn't secret. It's not enough to have a picture of my fingerprint, you have to produce a convincing enough fake of a real human with the right fingerprint. Take this to meatspace for a second. If you had a security guard sitting at a desk inspecting your hands and taking fingerprints you couldn't trick them with pictures. You can't hold up a picture of my face to a guard and expect that they'll suddenly think you're me. Biometric auth systems are trying to the same thing but without the human. > They are famously defeatable. And most locks in wide-use today are also defeatable by amateur locksmiths, that's not really the point. There are sophisticated biometric auth systems that aren't fooled by pictures. FaceID is one example.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoLet's suppose biometrics can be made nearly foolproof. Then somebody goes to all the effort to duplicate one. What then? Suicide I guess.
- warkdarrior 6y agoLet's suppose someone goes to all the effort to duplicate your biometrics in a real world scenario (e.g., going to the DMV). They put on their mask and their fake fingerprint and get a new driver license with your name and picture. Then they open bank accounts with it, get loans, and buy cars. What then? Suicide I guess.
- acdha 6y agoYou need to learn how these systems work before commenting further. First, you're wrong about the current biometric systems' sensor design — Touch ID and Face ID are not simple single frame cameras[1] so while spoofing is not impossible it's nowhere near as easy as you're claiming — and, more importantly, you're missing that the biometric is used to authenticate to the local device, not the remote service. If someone steals your phone, as soon as it's removed from your account the attacker has no access or way to gain access to your resources and they also do not have a copy of your biometric data. If I do get a full biometric from you, I cannot use that to add a new key-pair to your account without already having fully compromised it. That means that you're left with really unusual situations like someone stalking you with drones with 3-D infrared scanners who can't figure out how to have the same drone record your password when you type it in many times per day. 1. https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204587 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204587 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208108 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208108