8 ms·
I don't understand why people even ask for account creation. Now days the devices are personal, you don't have to have accounts to be identified, they are only
by mrtksn 6y ago
I don't understand why people even ask for account creation. Now days the devices are personal, you don't have to have accounts to be identified, they are only good to sync between devices(like multiple devices and account restoration). Especially with apps, the moment you install the app you have your details there for good and they don't go away accidentally like with the browsers.
I assume it's about tracking but now I'm beginning to suspect that it's simply a cargo cult mentality where no body asks why are we doing this.
I don't proceed with anything that requires a form to be filled without having a good reason. I'm actually positive that I have a bank account that doesn't have a login info, when I need to sign in from another device I would simply scan a barcode from the app to let me in.
Yet, there are apps asking me more questions than an immigration officer to let me use it.
- julienb_sea 6y agoTo be fair, I think there are some smart app developers clueing on this. I've sank pretty significant hours into some mobile games without ever creating a proper account. I only created an account once I cared enough to not lose the data. This is super smooth mobile UX especially for consumer facing apps, primarily those which have no immediate need at all to be cross platform.
- ivanagas 6y agoDuolingo is one that stands out for this.
- mcherm 6y ago> I'm actually positive that I have a bank account that doesn't have a login info I don't know where you are, but in the US it is actually illegal for a bank to offer financial services without collecting a significant amount of personal data from the customer. This exists for a few reasons but I think the most significant one is that the government does not want to give up the ability to block financial transactions for those they deem unacceptable. (Like terrorists.)
- mrtksn 6y agoI don’t have login info but the bank definitely collected the necessary personal information. It all makes sense, they are required to know me for AML reasons, so the account creation step collects this data. The bank is mobile first, so the account is activated through the app when my card arrives. Why would I have a username and password for the app that is used to create the account in first place? The app can keep it for me without exposing it to me ever. I can’t be phished for something that I don’t know and it is one less password to remember or take care.
- tgb 6y agoWhat's the process for if your phone dies or you lose it?
- mrtksn 6y agore—activation through scanning documents and taking a selfie. The process is initiated by entering your e-mail address.
- tgb 6y agoThanks for answering - not sure why someone would downvote someone directly answering a question!
- danlugo92 6y agoI think it's the people that made reddit... reddit (and digg before that) slowly coming over here, moderation has kept them at bay mostly, but quality has definitely dropped in hacker news
- jsjohnst 6y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html > Please don't post comments saying that HN is turning into Reddit. It's a semi-noob illusion, as old as the hills.
- dalbasal 6y agoCargo cult is an early stage of development, this is evolved to the point of having a logic of its own. It might just be a matter of boilerplate. The permissions and usernames are (in code, in legalese, etc) may be tied to the concept of a signup. They might have investors, advisors or whatnot asking about weekly registration trends or somesuch. They may have a regulator, and the regulator assumes that you have info. Even banks are increasingly getting regulator-ish. You may need to produce a "know-your-customer" policy. Anonymity just isn't done anymore.
- oblio 6y ago> Even banks are increasingly getting regulator-ish. You may need to produce a "know-your-customer" policy. That's an understatement, if I ever saw one. > Anonymity just isn't done anymore. When was banking anonymous? In the days of Bonnie and Clyde? :-)
- dalbasal 6y agoI mean operating anonymously at all, not banking anonymously.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rhizome 6y ago>Anonymity just isn't done anymore. Passive voice alert! By whom? Site/app producers can, with certain exceptions, choose to allow anonymity.
- SahAssar 6y agoYou're assuming a lot, especially about the willingness to install an app at all. I won't install an app unless it couldn't actually have been a webapp and I use it really often. Give me a proper website with a proper email/password/WebAuthN & SSO signup. I don't want the app, I don't want any of it.
- mrtksn 6y agoSure, I’m talking from my perspective. Websites are simply apps installed in the browser without asking for permission. Notorious for tracking abilities, data storage tied to the browser, performance lower, capabilities limited to browser api, data consumption unpredictable, identification tied to web technologies. Some people may want just that, I don’t judge.
- xfer 6y agoYou are pretending that apps don't do any of that? The only difference is you have control over your browser(you can filter tracking sites etc) but for an app you have none.
- mrtksn 6y agoThey all have their strengths and weaknesses. I favor the Apps more that websites because of what the web has become. Being able to know in what I am getting in and tapping install is much, much better experience than tapping on a link to the unknown then trying to figure out how to reach the thing I am looking for when the website tries to track me, monetize me, make me sign up all at the same time. A website would usually load about the same size data of a native app without a warning and would report me to facebook, google and others. That’s not something I am thrilled about.
- SahAssar 6y ago> load about the same size data of a native app without a warning and would report me to facebook, google and others Why do you think native apps are not like that? Many apps load SDKs from google and (especially) facebook. They often load a lot of assets from servers.
- sedatk 6y ago> you have your details there for good and they don't go away accidentally like with the browsers. But when it does go away (app reinstalls, phone upgrades, phone breaks etc), it causes a disproportionately catastrophic event: complete loss of access. Providing a simple email address would prevent this, but expecting the common user to have the wisdom on account recovery strategies is too optimistic. That's why many apps ask for email during registration. That can be tolerable for Discord, because your loss is just your friends list and access to some servers, which can be recovered easily through social means. That's not possible or feasible for every kind of app.
- mrtksn 6y agoFrom layman’s perspective it’s easy to reason that deleting an app or loosing the device will result in loose of data. You can easily offer an optional data safeguard feature for account restoration.
- ccktlmazeltov 6y agoso you mean registering with your phone or email?
- mrtksn 6y agoFor games, there’s Game Center in iOS. If that’s not an option, you can provide an option for the user to enter their e-mail, phone number or use “sign in with” service. Usually you can put it in the settings together with a badge seeking their attention. The idea is that, they already created an account by launching your code, so you don’t have to ask for account creation. Just ask for the information that is necessary to run your services and you can provide an optional method for account recovery.
- mastazi 6y agoAs a user who has switched back and forth between iOS and Android multiple times, Game Center isn’t gonna cut it for me. But I see how it could be enticing in some use cases.
- com2kid 6y agoLots of mobile games do this, you get a device tied account and then after you've played a bit they ask if you want to link to a real account to avoid losing progress.
- qppo 6y agoThe assumptions you usually have to make with that approach is: - The app is used on one device - Only one user has access to a device - There is a convenient or reliable way to identify a device for all platforms you target Plenty of apps can live with those, and plenty can't. email address is one of the least bad ways to do it.
- EGreg 6y agoHow can you prevent Sybil attacks?
- mrtksn 6y agoYou can check for real device. You can have rate limiters. You can request e-mail/phone validation before providing a valuable service. I guess depends on the nature of the situation.
- EGreg 6y agoApple Anonymous Attestation is the only thing I know about and it is just now available. And still rich people can afford toms of apple devices but at least it has a large cost.
- Meph504 6y agoWell because many services aren't just a mobile apps, and people use multiple devices, and devices have to be replaced from time to time, there are a lot of legit reasons for accounts. There are a lot of ways to mitigate having to make accounts, but many are less secure, more work, and most users at this point are use to creating an account.
- mrtksn 6y agoAccounts don’t have to be explicit. Ask only for the info that is necessary to provide your service and store it in auto generated account and provide a way to tie this account to some other account like e-mail or phone number for account restoration purposes.
- Meph504 6y agoI mean that sounds like a normal account registration process for most things that exist? what more are you typically putting in, other than an email address, maybe a username for uniqueness, etc...?
- mrtksn 6y agoThe main difference is that the user can start using the service right away and can secure the account some time later. You can use firebase accounts to manage that. Start with the anonymous account which will create an account with a random UID and use the mechanism to convert the accounts into “registered”. Pretty easy, you don’t even have to create your own custom solution.
- grawprog 6y ago>I don't understand why people even ask for account creation. Now days the devices are personal, you don't have to have accounts to be identified. Why would I want every single thing I do online to be directly linked to one physical real world device? It's not so much about data loss for me but I don't want anything real world linked to me to be used to authenticate me in any way other than monetary transactions or things with tangible physical value. Other than that, I have a range of email addresses and usernames I use depending on the nature of the site and the amount of personal information i'm willing to disclose. I have a fairly fine grained system for managing my user accounts accross various platforms and i'm personally finding it more and more aggravating the amount of places that require some kind of google or facebook sign in, let alone the idea that my phone should be my universal user account/name. The internet should be like the rest of public life. For the most part, in my day to day life, I get to choose the amount of personally identifiable information I disclose to others. Managing multiple user accounts with differing levels of personal information is the internet equivalent of this. I do not wish to be linked to one 'universal digital me' my real life interactions are not like that, why should my internet interactions be forced to be that way? I have different groups of friends, acquaintances, coworkers etc. I don't act the same way with all of them, I don't talk about the same things with all of them, they don't all have the same level of information about my life, yet increasingly, online interactions are being pushed into this 'one you for everyone and everything' paradigm that is completely antithetical to the original values of the early internet and human interaction in general.
- wlesieutre 6y ago> they are only good to sync between devices As an occasional discord user: yes, exactly. That's how Discord syncs communities and read messages between my phone, tablet, and computer, either via app or web client. This is a huge convenience over say IRC where (last time I looked) the way to get any client-side consistency is to run a personal 24/7 relay on your own server and use special clients to connect to that instead of the main IRC server. Which is the setup equivalent of not wanting a Dropbox account because "you can already build such a system yourself quite trivially by getting an FTP account, mounting it locally with curlftpfs, and then using SVN or CVS on the mounted filesystem."