3 ms·
I dunno. I mean, I do, it feels good. But it also is a very different kind of FIDO2 than what we've seen before. In a way that FIDO was designed for, that we ho
by rektide 6y ago
I dunno. I mean, I do, it feels good. But it also is a very different kind of FIDO2 than what we've seen before. In a way that FIDO was designed for, that we hoped would happen. But it's still not entirely joy & mirth that we're here for me.
It feels like a little like the first day we start to understand how "Big Tent" (in the OpenStack sense) FIDO2 ecosystem is. You can do whatever, make anything, and call it FIDO2; it's all duck typing: looks like a duck, quacks must be a duck. No implementation details are required, no transparency is needed, everything can be totally vendored way way up, and the standard will welcome you. Your platform is welcome here. This post is about how to use & prefer that platform, over the more common means available.
For sure this is overwhelmingly a good thing. It's by design that we allow platform authenticators in WebAuthn. Apple is allowing their closed, proprietary security technologies to seamlessly work on the web without making webdevs jump through hoops. It's a good thing, and this will really help Web Authentication for sure.
Still I have some wistfulness. It's a good user experience, it's great. It's a win for devs, it's a win for users. Still there's some larger context I can't quite put my finger on, when I see "authenticatorSelection: { authenticatorAttachment: "platform" }". The web is letting more of the native platform shine through, and that's good, but it also forgoes some of the knowability & commonality that resounds on so much of the rest of the web, and while the immediate impact is extremely good, I still think there's some kind of hard to describe ultra-slow-motion civilization-scale loss that's also passenger to this successful commingling of web and platform.
- StavrosK 6y agoSo what exactly is the concrete downside here, apart from the icky word "platform", that, in this context, means "a security chip that's not removable", ie as opposed to a Yubikey or such.
- sneak 6y agoWebsites will, at their option, be able to require Apple hardware to use them.
- reaperhulk 6y agoAttestation has allowed a website to lock to a specific vendor for 5+ years.
- jrmann100 6y agoLast I checked, Windows won't let you use self-signed attestation keys for your homemade devices.
- rektide 6y agoperhaps it's a totem, a reminder, that not all tech is interested in working together, that unlike the web itself you are entering an Apple or an Atari or Acorn specific encampment, for some random examples.