3 ms·
> Linux is the only mainstream kernel, free or proprietary, which doesn't have a sane and supported driver interface. I don't believe OpenBSD or FreeBSD has su
by jcranmer 6y ago
> Linux is the only mainstream kernel, free or proprietary, which doesn't have a sane and supported driver interface.
I don't believe OpenBSD or FreeBSD has such an interface either, and I'd classify those as mainstream kernels.
> However, what I don't see is that nVidia should have any obligation (ethical, legal or otherwise) of any sort to provide a Linux driver at all.
Well, they don't. But they have a commercial need for Linux support: their recent revenue growth has been in datacenter usage of GPUs, and Linux support is necessary for that computing environment. To that end, IMHO NVidia is the entity that needs to align its development practices to support the existing Linux driver community rather than Linux needing to align its process to accommodate NVidia's wishes.
This isn't to say that Linux has been right in its treatment of other external entities: the treatment of ZFS, as you note, does seem to be driven more by spite than actual technical reasons. But in the case of NVidia, there is definitely a good deal of fault on NVidia's side that needs to be acknowledged.
- rleigh 6y agoMy understanding is that FreeBSD freezes its kernel ABI for each major release and this enables third-party drivers to be written against it and supported for that major release. There are out-of-tree graphics drivers in the ports tree making use of this today. Both AMD and Nvidia drivers from what I can tell. Other non-graphics drivers as well. A freeze for a couple of years seems like a reasonable compromise to me. It's not forever, but it's long enough for third-parties to develop, validate and support a product for. The closest Linux gets to this is vendor kernels which are both vendor-specific, and highly-custom and badly dated. This at least gets you something reasonably current and supported to work with.