3 ms·
dang- it is not my intention to break guidelines here. The previous title was factually accurate, since the California Senate leader's name is listed among the
by mistrial9 6y ago
dang- it is not my intention to break guidelines here. The previous title was factually accurate, since the California Senate leader's name is listed among the authors. Please reconsider that this was "badly" editorialized.
- carabiner 6y agoUnless the original title is incredibly vague or generic ("Report from Committee, May 2019"), you should stick to that, rather than highlight (cherrypick) one fact from it to support a viewpoint. Even if that fact is "actually accurate."
- dang 6y agoSorry, I can see how 'badly' would land badly. I just meant that it isn't a borderline case. HN has that title rule for really good reasons and the submitted title clearly broke the rule. Let's not get too worried about that though. It's a good submission and that is 100x more important. Edit: maybe one clarification would help. Factual accuracy is good and necessary but not sufficient; there are many facts one could choose from, and cherry-picking the fact that you think is most important and making that be the title is a form of editorializing. It's actually the main form of editorializing. I grant you that the title you used is probably what most of us would consider most interesting, when looking at that article from the present moment.
- mistrial9 6y agothank you, I basically agree with your assessment
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]