7 ms·
I guess it'll take some more reading to understand this. Upshot: due to unprecedented warming and drying, California had tens of millions of dead trees. No amou
by JoeAltmaier 6y ago
I guess it'll take some more reading to understand this. Upshot: due to unprecedented warming and drying, California had tens of millions of dead trees. No amount of 'forest management' would have prevented this. And it was due to large regional climate changes.
This 'whistling in the dark' about simple explanations for climate change is not helping anybody.
<edit> Yes there was lots of thrashing around, and not all of it helped. But the last decade of drought created simultaneously 150 Million dead trees. It might have taken the combined industrial output of California for a decade to get them all cut, hauled and disposed. There was no time, most of the trees were in impassable terrain, and heck that activity would inevitably have created a few unintentional fires.
What was done or not done, couldn't have blunted the tsunami of dead wood that inundated the state. Arguing over a teacup in a tempest is fun but not informative.
- jeffbee 6y agoIsn't this report advocating that thinning the tree population would have blunted the effect of the bark beetle problem?
- JoeAltmaier 6y ago150 million dead trees. The problem is larger than any civil activity can encompass.
- jeffbee 6y agoNot sure about that. We already harvest half a billion trees every year. Those mechanized harvester-loaders are almost disturbingly effective. It doesn't seem like it would take very long to thin all those snags, if we made it a real policy goal.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoNot sure of those numbers. 3-4B board feet. 100 ft per tree? We're talking 30M trees. With the combined effort of all the equipment in every state, and usually in groomed tree farms. Not the mountains and wild places of California. And with an end result of millions of trash trees, not good lumber. It would arguably have cost more than the entire US lumber industry earns.
- pvaldes 6y agoThinning the tree population would not achieve anything. Many insects can fly several Km routinely. Bees do it constantly. The beetles probably could do it also. So either you remove all trees in a radius of lets say "4 km" or beetles just keep growint. But if you remove all trees in a few Km, then you don't have a forest anymore (neither water, wood, or the other environmental services that the forest provides). More pesticides equal to less birds and bats. Not having birds and bats plus sucking all the water that trees need equal to more beetles. The disdain of politicians (and their voters) for this themes is the root of this problem.
- jeffbee 6y agoSo, you didn't read the article? It doesn't say that making the trees further apart prevents the movement of the beetles, it's saying that the tree density is so high that the individual trees can't draw enough water to produce the sap that protects them from the beetles.
- pvaldes 6y agoIn reply to: >> Isn't this report advocating that thinning the tree population would have blunted the effect of the bark beetle problem? Thinning the tree population wouldn't solve it. Removing part of the dead trees could mitigate it but those trees are essential to beetle predators like woodpeckers. Things in ecology are complex and always connected. The real problem here is the lack of water.
- jeffbee 6y agoA snag doesn't draw any water, though, so it seems like you could leave them standing while culling live trees to reduce the areal water demand, right?
- pvaldes 6y ago> A snag doesn't draw any water I had seen this narrative lots of times before. "Fix it for me for free whereas I take the money" because you like the trees, don't you?. Not. Sorry. Is nor is my mission, neither I have the private resources to "draw any water" or fix the consequences of the greed of others. I assume that US government could fix the problem if they wanted, so don't blame on the messenger, please. The current narrative seems to be "forests are expensive so lets remove them and problem solved". Will not work.
- missedthecue 6y agoThere is a direct correlation between fire suppressive actions carried out over the last hundred or so years, and the increase of more devastating wildfires in California. The state government made it a practice to stifle any potential wildfire for so long that a significant overgrowth and buildup of flammable materials has occurred, which otherwise would have burned in minor incidents over the years. Mother Jones had a great piece on this - https://www.motherjones.com/environment/2017/12/a-century-of-fire-suppression-is-why-california-is-in-flames/ https://www.motherjones.com/environment/2017/12/a-century-of...
- bcrosby95 6y agoMaybe for far Northern California and the Sierras. But Southern California doesn't have much in the way of flammable materials other than grass and shrubs. And they grow back very quickly. One of my in-laws had to be evacuated 2 times in 3 years due to a fire in the same area.
- abernard1 6y ago> There is a direct correlation between fire suppressive actions carried out over the last hundred or so years, and the increase of more devastating wildfires in California. And yet, over the last 100 years, there weren't routine wildfires like this. It's only been the last 20 years--when underbrush management was prohibited because of environmental concerns--that we've had this problem.
- missedthecue 6y agoBecause the consequences of fire suppression take a fair bit of time to accumulate. You don't get 30 years of overgrown dry forest 1 year into fire suppression policies.
- abernard1 6y agoBut you do when those policies _began_ in the 70s. California's prohibiting underbrush removal due to environmentalism was just the preview of Delta Smelt Dust Bowls last decade. (The Dust Bowl, also being something that humans fixed with industrial policy, and the reason Oklahoma, despite no natural lakes, has more lakefront property per capita than anywhere in the U.S.)