3 ms·
We already have that in the US. We just call it "primaries" and "general election". It's not quite a completely open first round, but it's not uncommon for an o
by jfengel 6y ago
We already have that in the US. We just call it "primaries" and "general election". It's not quite a completely open first round, but it's not uncommon for an outsider to come in and win the support of a party without any prior experience with it. I don't think it makes Americans happy.
- jdashg 6y agoThe separate primaries make it a wildly different game. True run-off (common primary) is used in some states, such as California. In the case where one party wins both run-off slots, the system naturally selects the moderate. Great! However, in a two-party "run-off", the sides are pressured to polarize and rile up their voters. It's a very different game!
- jfengel 6y agoIt's different, but I don't think it's as different as you say. It's still a two stage process, and the primaries are generally open to anybody. The pressure to rile up voters exists either way. You saw this in the UK recently, where there are plenty of parties, and the election was incredibly awful. The winner of the election was, as usual, the one that had eliminated the second, third, and fourth parties that split the vote. I'm not saying there aren't differences, but I think it might help Americans to think of it as if it were more similar. They cast one vote, and if their candidate lost, they get to vote for their second favorite. It's not identical to a runoff election, but there are enough similarities to make me believe that a change to true runoff elections would not alter how people perceive the result.