17 ms·
Fire on the Mountain: Rethinking Forest Management in the Sierra Nevada (2018) [pdf]
- mistrial9 6y agoThis is a report by politicians, for politicians, predicting the massive and ongoing wildfires in California.
- KorematsuFred 6y agoAn invariably this will lead to "more taxes to protect our forests". As a state leading the climate change policies this tells you how miserable government will be in fighting climate change.
- mcint 6y agoWiki link (meager) since I hadn't heard of them before https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Hoover_Commission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Hoover_Commission > The California Little Hoover Commission (LHC), officially the Milton Marks "Little Hoover" Commission on California State Government Organization and Economy,[1] is an independent California state oversight agency modeled after the Hoover Commission and created in 1962, that investigates state government operations and promotes efficiency, economy and improved service through reports, recommendations and legislative proposals.[2] > Created by SB 37 in 1993, the California State Auditor operates under the direction of the Little Hoover Commission.[3] The cover page footer also mentions Milton Marks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milton_Marks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milton_Marks > Milton Marks, Jr. (July 22, 1920 – December 4, 1998) was a California politician who served in the California State Assembly and California State Senate, as both a Republican and a Democrat,[1] representing San Francisco for 38 years.[2] It's presumably named in deference to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hoover_Commission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hoover_Commission > The Hoover Commission, officially named the Commission on Organization of the Executive Branch of the Government, was a body appointed by President Harry S. Truman in 1947 to recommend administrative changes in the Federal Government of the United States. It took its nickname from former President Herbert Hoover, who was appointed by Truman to chair it.
- outside1234 6y ago""" * State leaders should continue to remind federal lawmakers and policymakers of federal obligations to its forests within California. * State agencies should plan to make greater use of the Good Neighbor Authority to perform treatments on federal land. """ 51% of forests in California are on Federal Land.
- criddell 6y agoAccording to this document, it's a bit higher than that: > By far the largest forest landowner in the state is the fed-eral government, which controls 57 percent of Californiaís forests.
- saas_sam 6y agoStates have authority to manage federal land within their borders. Edit since I'm getting downvoted: https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R44267.pdf https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R44267.pdf
- NeutronStar 6y agoThey have the authority, but do they have the duty? Also, "could" doesn't mean that they do. From your very own link: "States can obtain authority to own and manage federal lands within their borders only by federal, not state, law. Congress’s broad authority over federal lands includes the authority to dispose of lands, and Congress can choose to transfer ownership of federal land to states. States have legal authority to manage federal lands within their borders to the extent Congress has given them such authority. As an example, Congress has to a large extent allowed states to exercise management authority over wildlife as a traditional area of state concern. Congress could give states authority to manage certain other activities, resources, or other aspects of federal lands. Congress also could give federal agencies authority to delegate or assign responsibility for aspects of federal land management to states or other partners."
- onecommentman 6y agoPerhaps this addresses some questions https://www.gov.ca.gov/2020/08/13/california-u-s-forest-service-establish-shared-long-term-strategy-to-manage-forests-and-rangelands/ https://www.gov.ca.gov/2020/08/13/california-u-s-forest-serv...
- thehappypm 6y agoCalifornia is an odd place. Dry, warm, and sunny, surrounded by deserts on two sides and slowly fading to a wet climate in the north. In the desert there are few trees. In the lush PNW trees do well, generally. Is it any surprise that dry California is so prone to fires? It’s the edge of the forest ecosystem, the last stand before it gives way to dry desert.
- conductr 6y agoI’m in Texas but it’s pretty much common sense that after drought years your fire risks are elevated. When everyone was talking about the drought in CA a few years ago was it really a stretch of the imagination that fires would follow?
- prewett 6y agoThe fires are the worst in wet years, generally. It rains all winter, at least in the north part of the state, so lots of underbrush grows. It doesn't rain at all in the summer, so all the brush dries out, providing fuel for the fires. But a bigger problem is that all the forests are wild, so over time all that underbrush grows up and then a fire starts and burns everything down. If there were regular fires than the underbrush would burn quickly leaving the trees unharmed.
- conductr 6y agoProbably looking at it similarly but slightly different lens. My take is that wet years trees don’t die off in large numbers. Drought years kill enough trees that the forest can ignite. The death of the trees a few years ago allowed the fast growing underbrush to become big enough to create the problem there. The dead trees remain to move the problem up. The living trees are engulfed by hot and long burning fires that surround.
- bigbubba 6y ago> Paleoclimatological studies indicate that the last 150 years of California's history have been unusually wet compared to the previous 2000 years. Tree stumps found at the bottom of lakes and rivers in California indicate that many water features dried up during historical dry periods, allowing trees to grow there while the water was absent. These dry periods were associated with warm periods in Earth's history. During the Medieval Warm Period, there were at least two century-long megadroughts with only 60-70% of modern precipitation levels. Paleoclimatologists believe that higher temperatures due to global warming may cause California to enter another dry period, with significantly lower precipitation and snowpack levels than observed over the last 150 years.[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_change_in_California https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_change_in_California Welcome to normal. I think California is so young, many people living in California just don't have a realistic expectation for California's climate.
- floren 6y agoI've been reading Dan De Quille's "The Big Bonanza", about the history of the Nevada silver mines, and I was struck by a sentence from an early chapter: > Pointing out the blue peaks of the Marysville Buttes, seen far away in the smoky distance, [Kit Carson] said "Yonder lies the valley of the Sacramento!" This was in 1846; was it smoky because of persistent forest fires? Since it was still before the gold rush, the foothills of the Sierra Nevadas presumably weren't particularly populous.
- shoreofwonder 6y ago> The name "Smoky" comes from the natural fog that often hangs over the range and presents as large smoke plumes from a distance. Wikipedia, "Great Smoky Mountains".
- floren 6y agoGood point, it could have just been a figure of speech to refer to natural fog or clouds.
- mannykannot 6y ago
- supernova87a 6y agoI thought a core issue was that if you just throw firefighting money at a problem, the (well-intentioned and honorable) fire-fighting forces will find ways to use that money. Which long-term, turns into incentivizing the putting out of fires, rather than the prevention of fires (brush clearance, controlled burns, reducing/managing human encroachment into fire-vulnerable areas). And creating almost a fire-industrial complex that justifies why you need so spend so much money.
- tedtonks87 6y agoThis claim should not be made lightly -- do you have any sources to back up your claim? I imagine the money spent on local and state fire departments does not subtract from the NPS/BLM budget for forest management.
- supernova87a 6y agoI do not, except from sporadic NPR series on the costs of wildfire fighting versus lack of attention on wildfire prevention. The governor just committed another $2B (I recall), and much of it to go to fighting I believe. Honestly, I would be glad to see some analysis and find that my uninformed impression is incorrect. I also find it interesting that I'm being downvoted for raising such a fundamental question. As if the money is clearly being used in the right way. More money for planes, firefighters, modeling fire behavior: https://www.gov.ca.gov/2020/07/09/ahead-of-peak-fire-season-governor-newsom-announces-more-firefighting-support-amid-covid-19-pandemic/ https://www.gov.ca.gov/2020/07/09/ahead-of-peak-fire-season-... https://lao.ca.gov/Publications/Report/4172 https://lao.ca.gov/Publications/Report/4172 Although some discussion of prevention: https://www.npr.org/2020/06/07/867395353/california-was-set-to-spend-over-1-billion-to-prevent-wildfires-then-came-covid- https://www.npr.org/2020/06/07/867395353/california-was-set-...
- ehnto 6y agoI suspect the budget is actually a fair bit more nuanced than a dichotomy of fighting versus prevention, but regardless, the tools, training and people used to fight fires are the same tools and people that go out and do the preventative measures. I wouldn't be worried about the macro budget, look at your actual firefighting policies and decide from those if the money will end up spent well.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pbreit 6y agoVery little to do with climate change. Mostly to do with lousy forest management.
- missedthecue 6y agoOf all the takes out there, this one seems most reasonable. There are plenty of areas with much more forest per square km that are not up in flames year after year, but they're just as impacted by the global climate. No one has ever been able to explain to me why the climate seems only picks on CA, and why it has nothing to do with the decades and decades of fire suppression they've been doing that have built up a huge tinder box in a drought-prone area.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoI guess it'll take some more reading to understand this. Upshot: due to unprecedented warming and drying, California had tens of millions of dead trees. No amount of 'forest management' would have prevented this. And it was due to large regional climate changes. This 'whistling in the dark' about simple explanations for climate change is not helping anybody. <edit> Yes there was lots of thrashing around, and not all of it helped. But the last decade of drought created simultaneously 150 Million dead trees. It might have taken the combined industrial output of California for a decade to get them all cut, hauled and disposed. There was no time, most of the trees were in impassable terrain, and heck that activity would inevitably have created a few unintentional fires. What was done or not done, couldn't have blunted the tsunami of dead wood that inundated the state. Arguing over a teacup in a tempest is fun but not informative.
- jeffbee 6y agoIsn't this report advocating that thinning the tree population would have blunted the effect of the bark beetle problem?
- JoeAltmaier 6y ago150 million dead trees. The problem is larger than any civil activity can encompass.
- bjustin 6y agoA report like this is good news, in that we have a single item we can point to that says what the problems are and what we can do about them. The numerous large fires in 2018 and 2020 help make the case for taking the report seriously and urgently. So what can citizens who are not in government do to move this along?
- dirtypersian 6y agovote the right people in to power!
- xyzzyz 6y agoCalifornia could stop voting for the same people over and over again. After enough iterations, the only two possibilities left are that either Californians are victims to widespread false consciousness, or that they support the path their state is proceeding on.
- dang 6y agoThe submitted title ("State of California Knew the Fires Were Coming") was badly editorialized, which breaks the site guideline about titles [1]. We take submission privileges away from accounts that do that, so please don't do that. All is not lost though. If you want to say what you think is important about an article, you're welcome to. Indeed, that's helpful. Just please do it as a comment in the thread. Then your view will be on a level playing field with everyone else's [2]. The main thing we're trying to avoid is submitters using the title field to promote their interpretation of an article. Titles are by far the largest influence on threads, so it's important that they reflect the underlying content neutrally. Otherwise, simply by virtue of being the first (or luckiest) person to submit an article, one user would have the power to frame it for everyone else, and that would lead to an entirely different kind of site. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html [2] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=%22level%20playing%20field%22%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...
- mistrial9 6y agodang- it is not my intention to break guidelines here. The previous title was factually accurate, since the California Senate leader's name is listed among the authors. Please reconsider that this was "badly" editorialized.
- carabiner 6y agoUnless the original title is incredibly vague or generic ("Report from Committee, May 2019"), you should stick to that, rather than highlight (cherrypick) one fact from it to support a viewpoint. Even if that fact is "actually accurate."
- dang 6y agoSorry, I can see how 'badly' would land badly. I just meant that it isn't a borderline case. HN has that title rule for really good reasons and the submitted title clearly broke the rule. Let's not get too worried about that though. It's a good submission and that is 100x more important. Edit: maybe one clarification would help. Factual accuracy is good and necessary but not sufficient; there are many facts one could choose from, and cherry-picking the fact that you think is most important and making that be the title is a form of editorializing. It's actually the main form of editorializing. I grant you that the title you used is probably what most of us would consider most interesting, when looking at that article from the present moment.
- zests 6y agoAre there any "controlled burns over time" statistics? I'd venture that "not enough controlled burns" should be the first hypothesis for why these fires are so common. I learned how important controlled burns are in boy scouts -- this isn't exactly a well kept secret. Before any other explanations are suggested, this one should be addressed. I'd also venture that the state of California would prefer if the fires were outside of their control rather than caused by forest mismanagement. I will neglect to mention any other political reasons that might influence what these fires are blamed on. Can anyone who rejects the controlled burns hypothesis explain the basis of their beliefs and also explain what they think would happen if the frequency of controlled burns were increased?
- mcint 6y agoNo. CalFire has reports on their response to crises, but no statistics on preventative measures. It hasn't been what's driving promotions. They can't change incentives placed on them. And we have to be willing to voluntarily accept man-caused air quality tradeoffs (and e.g. make liability exemptions, or have the state pay for harm caused by the side effects of intentional, planned burns) - Most recent "Redbook": https://www.fire.ca.gov/media/11146/2018_redbook_final.pdf https://www.fire.ca.gov/media/11146/2018_redbook_final.pdf - "Stats and Events": https://www.fire.ca.gov/stats-events/ https://www.fire.ca.gov/stats-events/ - "Vegetation Management Program" (sub-programs (2-tick "--") existence and structure shows how much CalFire has been able to invest in these): https://www.fire.ca.gov/programs/resource-management/resource-protection-improvement/vegetation-management-program/ https://www.fire.ca.gov/programs/resource-management/resourc... -- Forest Practice (other portals mentioned here): https://www.fire.ca.gov/programs/resource-management/forest-practice/ https://www.fire.ca.gov/programs/resource-management/forest-... --- Open Data Hub, mainly timber mgmt: https://forest-practice-calfire-forestry.hub.arcgis.com/ https://forest-practice-calfire-forestry.hub.arcgis.com/ -- ...Landowner Assistance: https://www.fire.ca.gov/programs/resource-management/resource-protection-improvement/landowner-assistance/ https://www.fire.ca.gov/programs/resource-management/resourc... -- Environmental (e.g. Air quality): https://www.fire.ca.gov/programs/resource-management/resource-protection-improvement/environmental-protection-program/ https://www.fire.ca.gov/programs/resource-management/resourc... --- CEQA CA Env. Quality Act: https://wildlife.ca.gov/Conservation/CEQA/Purpose#what https://wildlife.ca.gov/Conservation/CEQA/Purpose#what -- Climate Change: https://www.fire.ca.gov/programs/resource-management/climate-change-and-energy/ https://www.fire.ca.gov/programs/resource-management/climate...
- iongoatb 6y agoWarmer and drier areas are definitely more likely to start a fire. Climate change causes places to be warmer and drier over the long-term. However, this long-term trend, which is worrisome, does not explain the magnitude of the fires that have been haunting California the past few years. The Governor was wrong when he said that it is mostly caused by climate change and only partially due to forest management. It's the other way around.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]