3 ms·
Isn't the resistance to official backdoors the enormous downside to a crack or hack? That is, everyone knows there's an official backdoor in Chromium encryption
by bediger4000 6y ago
Isn't the resistance to official backdoors the enormous downside to a crack or hack? That is, everyone knows there's an official backdoor in Chromium encryption. All criminals and all nation state cryptanalysis orgs start in on it. The Romanians crack it. The crack gets used to siphon money from all kinds of accounts. Now Google has to replace all instances of Chromium for everyone to be safe. Huge PR and money downside.
You can change "Chromium" to "Safari" and "Google" to "Apple" and "Romanians" to whoever you like. Once the encryption or the backdoor or whatever is broken, there's a crisis. Google/Apple/Microsoft has to figure out what to do, and how to get the change past the various government certifications, and deal with the PR fallout.
If this happens 3 times, e-commerce becomes a thing of suspicion: nobody will want to have bank accounts on line.
There's some obvious 2nd order effects:
Slower development cycles. Every change has to be certified as a good back door by opaque government entities, from multiple governments. What a nightmare!
Open source goes away. If the source is available, someone recompiles without the backdoor. Illegal! Now we've got to ban open source. This is probably a good thing from the copyright maximalist position, but for nobody else.
Next order effect, is that governments will periodically sample traffic or test the backdoors to see if they work. They will find shady people with fake backdoors or encrypted-encryption with an unknown/better interior algorithm. This will lead to a lot of monitoring to ensure that only criminals have fake backdoors or better encryption.
There's a whole row of knock-on effects, every few of them with any benefit.
- gentleman11 6y agoThe internet is ubiquitous today because people trust it, where in the past they did not. Many seniors still will avoid online banking because of this. After a few massive hacks, the whole internet and the economy built on it will regress 2 decades
- kwhat4 6y agoI think the governments all still want strong encryption, but with a man-in-the-middle style eavesdrop point at the tech company where the NSA or whoever can perform their inspection on all the communication flowing through the service. This is certainly not to protect the children but more likely for terrorist monitoring with the added bonus of vacuuming up your dick pics. It should be more secure than back-dooring AES/RSA/ECC, but it still has the potential to compromise quite a bit of information and basically does away with what little privacy any end user has left.
- lostcolony 6y agoOf course they do. They want a mathematically perfect, impossible to crack system, that also happens to have a common key that works for everything, that they alone own. And by 'they', I mean their government. Not enemy governments. What happens when (not if) that common key leaks or is abused is not their concern. Until, of course, it invariably happens, and they find their citizens having their bank accounts siphoned, their agents being discovered and blackmailed for their basic 'civilian' internet use, etc.
- kwhat4 6y agoThere is no common key in the MITM scenario. It's still securely encrypted using over the counter algorithms, but instead of the end users exchanging keys, you exchange with the MITM and different key sets are used by both parties.
- lostcolony 6y agoFair enough; logic still applies. A criminal element just needs to comprise the MITM to compromise all communication flowing through it.