3 ms·
I initally intended to read 100 random Reddit threads, counting posts containing blockquotes with those not, and counting total inflammatory posts in either cas
by thaumaturgy 18y ago
I initally intended to read 100 random Reddit threads, counting posts containing blockquotes with those not, and counting total inflammatory posts in either case.
I've done four now and I'm getting really antsy.
I'd love to come up with an algorithm to automate this, but discerning a troll post from an inflammatory post from an informative post algorithmically is an Engineering-Very-Hard problem [http://fishbowl.pastiche.org/2007/07/17/understanding_engineers_feasibility http://fishbowl.pastiche.org/2007/07/17/understanding_engine...].
Anyway, of the four, so far the results have been surprising: Out of 457 total read comments, there were only 25 blockquotes. Of the 25 blockquotes, there were 5 that I (totally subjectively) considered "inflammatory", either because of a strong personal attack, or because of a deliberate misquote of the author ("FTFY"). I only counted 15 inflammatory posts not containing a blockquote -- clearly, I wasn't counting comments that were just lame, tired repetitions of a meme, lacking content, etc.
Because the sample set's so small, there isn't enough information for statistical significance one way or the other. However, in [http://www.reddit.com/info/6s09o/comments/ http://www.reddit.com/info/6s09o/comments/], I did notice that there was a pattern where posts containing blockquotes in a thread tended to be longer, better written, more precise responses to the previous comment. The thread might devolve into a pedantic debate between two people, but it was still more of a discussion than many of the other threads that didn't contain blockquotes at all.
- ars 18y agoI quite agree with this. People will be nasty with or without blockquoting. But with blockquoting you'll sometimes have very detailed line by line replies/discussions. And compared to what's usually on reddit that's a big improvement. I assume the same will happen here. (Although you're starting with a better base, so either you'll get a better result, or you'll revert to the median, i.e. make it worse. No way to find out but to try.)