4 ms·
Why do you need to keep such close tabs on your wife’s location to the point where you need geofencing? Does she have some sort of disability or do you live som
by kortilla 6y ago
Why do you need to keep such close tabs on your wife’s location to the point where you need geofencing? Does she have some sort of disability or do you live somewhere extremely dangerous?
I’m just having trouble wrapping my mind around tracking that used to be reserved for criminals wearing ankle bracelets.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- throwaways885 6y agoMaybe some less Orwellian context: It's very normal now for friends/family to have some kind of permanent location sharing. Snapchat has this feature built in and I was quite surprised to see dozens of friends have this feature turned on and widely sharing by default.
- michaelt 6y agoPartner A: Please send me a message when you leave work, so I know when to start making dinner (or not to wait, if you're working late) and not to worry you might have been in an accident. Partner B: I'd be happy to, but as I'm forgetful when I'm busy working late, and me forgetting will make you worry, we should use something that works automatically. (Add or remove going to the gym, stopping by the store on the way home, getting a beer on Friday...) Obviously, you could accomplish the same thing by reliably leaving work at the same time every day - but some would say ceding authority over your own schedule is a greater indignity than ceding privacy over your current location.
- kortilla 6y ago> and not to worry you might have been in an accident. Partner A sounds like he/she might have some deeper separation anxiety or trust issues to work through. Being out of contact for multiple hours should be normal without conjuring up worries about accidents. Has partner B ever been in an accident on the way home? Would worrying somehow prevent it? If partner B stops for more than the pre-approved amount of time at a given stop light, how many seconds does it take for partner A’s panic to set in? 60 seconds? Remember, B could have gotten into an accident and seconds matter! Partner A needs to chill the fuck out and remember that partner B is a functioning adult that can survive multiple hours without the observation and worry of partner A.
- robertlagrant 6y agoAh, an internet psychiatrist and control freak all in one.
- kortilla 6y agoI don’t know about control freak but setting alerts based on someone’s location is pretty controlling and obsessive.
- robertlagrant 6y ago> Partner A needs to chill the fuck out and remember that partner B is a functioning adult that can survive multiple hours without the observation and worry of partner A. Telling people on the internet what to do. Doesn't sound very un-control freaky.
- Dayshine 6y ago> Partner A needs to chill the fuck out and remember that partner B is a functioning adult that can survive multiple hours without the observation and worry of partner A. Partner A can survive just fine, but partner B is hungry and wants to have dinner. Partner B isn't responding to queries about whether Partner A should eat. Is this: a. Partner B is on the way home and so can't respond b. Partner B is engrossed in work/a meeting/shopping and so can't respond, but won't be back soon If a -> Wait If b -> Eat food What on earth does that have to do with separation anxiety?
- kortilla 6y agoThe message I replied to is about being concerned about the partner being in an accident if the partner doesn’t reply. The ancestor post is about defining geofencing so the partner can get movement notifications on the other partner. This has nothing to do with being hungry. This is a person with separation anxiety or control issues.
- 6y ago
- watwut 6y agoIt still sounds like over the top. If your adult partner works late a lot, then you should not worry when your adult partner is coming late. It is very safe to assume that your partner is working late again. In this case, the partner A seems to have too much anxiety or obsession regarding normal schedule of partner B. I mean this 100%. Healthy relationships do not require "ceding authority over own schedule" nor non-stop tracking. If partner acted like A in your example, I would seen that as a red flag and sign of controlling personality.
- michaelt 6y ago> If your adult partner works late a lot, then you should not worry when your adult partner is coming late. Not worrying is all very well, but imagine the family dinner starts cooking at 6pm, is ready to eat at 6:30pm, and has gone cold by 6:45pm. And imagine this timing works fine 9 days out of 10. It's reasonable for whoever is doing the cooking to want to know - ideally at 6pm and certainly at 6:30pm - whether their partner is on time, running 5 minutes late, or running an hour late. > Healthy relationships do not require "ceding authority over own schedule" People do that all the time - A person who has promised their partner they'll get home by 6:30pm every evening for dinner has ceded control over their schedule. Nothing unusual about that. > I would seen that as a red flag and sign of controlling personality. A partner who will have dinner ready when you get home from work doesn't seem like a red flag to me.
- watwut 6y agoIn your situation, I would simply start to eat along with children, because they are hungry and have bed time. Even if you called, you cant reasonably expect everyone to wait for you with dinner for an hour. I would also expect the partner to let me know in advance, but if he is forgetful we would either eat or call. > People do that all the time - A person who has promised their partner they'll get home by 6:30pm every evening for dinner has ceded control over their schedule. Nothing unusual about that. I was literally reacting to parent who said this: "you could accomplish the same thing by reliably leaving work at the same time every day - but some would say ceding authority over your own schedule is a greater indignity than ceding privacy over your current location." In any case, promising something is not ceding authority by any reasonable definition. Parent claimed that having partners location all the time is necessary to avoid "ceding authority over schedule". Theory was his, not mind > A partner who will have dinner ready when you get home from work doesn't seem like a red flag to me. When that requires constant location tracking, then it is red flag. If your schedule have you coming in within an hour long span, I find it odd to organize the dinner so that it is done exactly wherever you come it. I would expect the dinner be more regular, at the time when you are usually already at home.
- renewiltord 6y agoWe just have a different value calculus over you. My friends have my location. I share it pretty liberally with everyone close to me comfortable to receive it. It's convenient for me since they know how far I am when I'm heading over. They can tell if I'm in town if they want to go out. Honestly, never felt uncomfortable.
- kortilla 6y agoYou sharing with your friends is not the same use case at all. We’re talking about someone setting up geofencing on their partner so they get notifications when they leave/arrive specific areas. That’s obsessive controlling behavior completely independent of you just making your location available for people to see.
- renewiltord 6y agoHmm, strangely, I simulated this in my head and I would feel a little uncomfortable with the push-nature of this in the worst case. Like if a friend used my location sharing to set fences to see when I'm going to a specific location and measured that, etc. But if they used the fence around their own home to be like "Hey, when's he near my place so I can see if he wants to come hang" I think I'd like that. So perhaps, to me, the thing that makes me happy is intent. I bucket these people into high-trust so I expect them to not do the weird one (and they won't even do the latter).
- slow_donkey 6y agoYou're assuming he setup the geofence on his partner's phone when that's not a detail actually mentioned. We just know his wife happens has location sharing enabled.
- michaelbrooks 6y agoMy wife is a pet sitter and has been bitten by a dog. She called me, but couldn't explain or tell me her location and me being terrible with directions drove around aimlessly and couldn't find her. After this, she decided it was best we both share our locations so we know each other's location just in case something like this happens again. The geofencing thing would be so I could time when to start cooking dinner and have it ready for when she gets in. I work from home so it's easy for me to cook and I just like to have it ready and stay warm by the time she gets in.