3 ms·
This doesn't pass a sniff test: - No details; promise to "leak" details later (but that never happened, and this page seems from ~2013?) - Emotional language
by arp242 6y ago
This doesn't pass a sniff test:
- No details; promise to "leak" details later (but that never happened, and this page seems from ~2013?)
- Emotional language doesn't inspire confidence in reasonable and rational thinking about this, and it doesn't consider the possibility that Cutts was merely mistaken in his email, or mixed things up, or that there is something else not obvious that could explain the email.
- Calls the Google ranking algorithm a "penalty"; that this penalizes pages with quotations and the like is unfortunate, but lifting text from random websites is a a technique spammers use frequently. This is a rather unnuanced way to describe it.
- Even the mysterious "whistleblower" email doesn't strike me as very convincing.
- Insinuation that the site is penalized just because Cutts has ties to UrbanDictionary; which strikes me as unlikely.
Are parts of it true? Probably. The "automated penalty" probably is, but I wouldn't phrase it like that myself. The rest? Meh.
- donatzsky 6y ago> No details; promise to "leak" details later (but that never happened, and this page seems from ~2013?) Last update was October 2020. That he intends to release the whistle-blower mails with full headers suggest that he has confidence that they were sent from Google servers. We'll see, I guess. Do agree that the language leans a bit too much in the emotional/conspiracy direction. Really doesn't help his case.
- lebaux 6y agoAdd: - no SSL because there was "no time"? It is trivial to enable SSL on such a simple website. - the person has no idea how SEO works, I see no mention on noindex, nofollow, disavow or other common thingies to fight penalties. I don't like google at all, just look at my twitter, but as arp242 said, this doesn't pass the sniff test at all.